3 ms·
Interesting that they went to visit the Blender offices, considering Blender still has it's own video editor (that seems to be ramping up on receiving improveme
by embedding-shape 7mo ago
Interesting that they went to visit the Blender offices, considering Blender still has it's own video editor (that seems to be ramping up on receiving improvements as of late too) which is basically a "competitor" (as far as FOSS has competitors) to Kdenlive.
I'd love to know more what actually went down there, is there plans about sharing of code or something similar, considering the two applications serve similar use cases when it comes to video editing?
- prmoustache 7mo agoOpen source projects do not necessary see alternatives as "competitors" if they don't market/sell their software.
- embedding-shape 7mo agoGreat work responding to the only point I tried to make as weak as possible, and even provided an explanation for why it isn't "correct" in the first place...
- nathanmills 7mo agoCalling FOSS devs "competitors" is such a corporate-minded statement that completely misses the point. FOSS devs all work together to achieve a common goal and don't see other projects as competitors, they see them as friends.
- embedding-shape 7mo agoI agree, that what I literally tried to qualify it... Goddamn some of you seem to write comments with the sole purpose to disagree with the smallest of things.
- elteto 7mo agoCompetition for non-monetary resources is absolutely a thing. Developer time is scarce and other projects can absolutely see others as competitors in this regard. We have plenty of stories of project forks sprouting because of frustration/disagreement/etc and the new fork starts gathering more attention/contributions because of better governance, better devx, saner environment, etc.
- darkwater 7mo agoYes, but this is not a case of project hard fork, not even a soft fork. They are two completely unrelated projects. People contributing to KDE would probably not contribute to Gnome for a variety of reasons - and vice versa - and it's perfectly fine. One aspect of open source is biodiversity.
- swaits 7mo agoComrade, thank you for correcting the record. The word "competitor" has been retired from the lexicon effective immediately. All FOSS developers are friends. All FOSS developers have always been friends. Anyone who remembers otherwise will be assisted by the Ministry of Love in recovering the correct memory.
- kristianp 7mo agoThis is hacker news. Every opinion you write will be greeted with an argument for the opposite opinion. It's par for the course on here.
- TehCorwiz 7mo agoBlender is a wild untamed beast of a thousand panels. Those who wrangle the beast are wise and powerful. But they became that was from the journey. Kdenlive is a much more approachable quest for someone who is just entering the dungeon.
- embedding-shape 7mo agoWhat's great about Blender, is that if you learn the UI, controls and hotkeys for the purposes of 3D, you can basically use the same UI, controls and hotkeys for video editing, and vice-versa of course :) People overplay how unfriendly it is nowadays too, very far from how it was a decade ago, when it was really hard to understand how the UI and UX worked.
- TehCorwiz 7mo agoOh, don't get me wrong. I love it at tinker with it regularly. But power comes with complexity. It's always a trade off.
- Narishma 7mo agoIt's been ages since I last tried Blender, is it still unusable without a numpad?
- 7jjjjjjj 7mo agoNo, I use Blender a lot and don't even know what they have mapped to the numpad.
- embedding-shape 7mo agoI think I use Numpad 0 daily for "Change viewport view to camera view", but surely it can be rebound like most other shortcuts, don't think there is a requirement to have a Numpad, afaik.
- eichin 7mo agoyeah, my one use of kdenlive has been to slap an on-screen telemetry track over a video - and it worked great for that, speaking as someone who has no interest in video editing :-)