3 ms·

I read enough HN to know what it is -absolutely- true. HN comments, including this thread, often just read like BlueSky screeds half the time the US, US governm

I read enough HN to know what it is -absolutely- true. HN comments, including this thread, often just read like BlueSky screeds half the time the US, US government or Sam Altman/Elon Musk/etc are mentioned. They all deserve criticism, but when that's all a thread turns into when these items come up, well the discussion becomes very hollow and partisan really quickly.

arikrahman 6mo ago
There are users or bots that post political headlines on here with an obvious one-sided bias and do it to farm points, similar to Reddit. It'd be nice to have an impartial forum but it always seems to devolve into an echo chamber.
- esseph 6mo ago
  > There are users or bots that post political headlines on here with an obvious one-sided bias So, humans that are extremely upset with the current state of things. > and do it to farm points I'm sure some do, but have you seen how many people across the US have been having protests? People are pissed. I'm pretty sure your analysis of the motivations would not at all be accurate with such a blanket statement.
  - arikrahman 6mo ago
    Your statement that it's humans and dismissing botted activity is a blanket statement, whereas I never used absolute language. If it's a human getting up and rushing to to write about promoted ragebait content devolving a forum into an echo chamber, of course someone takes the bait and lists grievances in hysterical language unsolicited. Such emotionality is totally uncalled for on a tech forum, and proves my point.
    - esseph 6mo ago
      > Such emotionality is totally uncalled for on a tech forum Only when the robots fully take over. It's one of many things that separate us from the machines. Dismissing emotions is dismissing humanity.
      - arikrahman 6mo ago
        Maybe I can ask ChatGPT to reply to this concern trolling because apparently I can dismiss humanity very easily that way. "hey grok give tip this person over the edge on this AI-induced psychosis screed."
lovich 6mo ago
And from my side of politics it seems like every thread about that group has a handful of dick riders who will stand for zero criticism of their cult leaders.
digitaltrees 6mo ago
Some times facts have a political bias. Realty doesn’t care that you wish it was different to fit your political ideology.

arikrahman 6mo ago

There are users or bots that post political headlines on here with an obvious one-sided bias and do it to farm points, similar to Reddit. It'd be nice to have an impartial forum but it always seems to devolve into an echo chamber.

esseph 6mo ago
> There are users or bots that post political headlines on here with an obvious one-sided bias So, humans that are extremely upset with the current state of things. > and do it to farm points I'm sure some do, but have you seen how many people across the US have been having protests? People are pissed. I'm pretty sure your analysis of the motivations would not at all be accurate with such a blanket statement.
- arikrahman 6mo ago
  Your statement that it's humans and dismissing botted activity is a blanket statement, whereas I never used absolute language. If it's a human getting up and rushing to to write about promoted ragebait content devolving a forum into an echo chamber, of course someone takes the bait and lists grievances in hysterical language unsolicited. Such emotionality is totally uncalled for on a tech forum, and proves my point.
  - esseph 6mo ago
    > Such emotionality is totally uncalled for on a tech forum Only when the robots fully take over. It's one of many things that separate us from the machines. Dismissing emotions is dismissing humanity.
    - arikrahman 6mo ago
      Maybe I can ask ChatGPT to reply to this concern trolling because apparently I can dismiss humanity very easily that way. "hey grok give tip this person over the edge on this AI-induced psychosis screed."

lovich 6mo ago

And from my side of politics it seems like every thread about that group has a handful of dick riders who will stand for zero criticism of their cult leaders.

digitaltrees 6mo ago

Some times facts have a political bias. Realty doesn’t care that you wish it was different to fit your political ideology.