7 ms·
Firestorm Erupts Over Virginia's Education Goals
- rayiner 14y agoI think there is value in taking into account the starting point of various schools in setting goals, but I can't believe they would be dumb enough to use a suspect classification (race) as the metric instead of something like socioeconomic status or the original passing rates for individual schools.
- anigbrowl 14y agoSocioeconomic status is hard to measure directly without requesting a lot of family data, and school data is not that fine-grained. If you're trying to measure relative improvement year-on-year, then race is a statistically useful proxy. I don't think it's stupid at all. Although it's predictably offensive, in that it seems expectations or effort are lowered for less well-performing groups, it's time people get to grips with the fact that kids do not all start out with the same opportunities, but are in many cases held back by circumstances before the first day of school.
- jivatmanx 14y agoHow is race more fine-grained than the socioeconomic status of individual schools?
- tptacek 14y agoIt's not; the socioeconomic data is just hard for schools to get.
- jivatmanx 14y agoReally? I understand the difficulty in getting data for individual students, but for the areas that a school serves, I figured that there was some sort of public demographic data for them. If it is, than they could simply use past test scores, giving a curve for schools that have done the worst in past years.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWhy would you expect the socioeconomic status of all students at a school to be the same?
- jivatmanx 14y agoAssuming five races: Given that there are more than five schools, than using a school's past score performance or socioeconomic status is going to be closer to their individual score than the aggregate for their race. tl;dr School is finer grained than race because there are more schools than races.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat only works when you are able to control for all other factors.
- rayiner 14y agoBecause school districts in the US are shockingly segregated by both race and income.
- jivatmanx 14y agoA consequence of school funding being based entirely on local property taxes.
- rayiner 14y agoAnd let's face it: also some of our own segregationist instincts. Even liberal San Francisco recently abandoned its eminently egalitarian policy of mixing up the public school population by not basing assignments on neighborhood. I'm not the only progressive who cringes at the thought of not being able to buy my daughter into a particular type of school district.
- fusiongyro 14y agoThe school does, however, have detailed information on how students were performing the previous year which they can use without tarnishing themselves with this "statistically useful proxy" that happens to also amount to political suicide. The problem with doing that isn't that it is difficult, it's that it doesn't introduce enough misdirection for them to get away with what they're trying to get away with. What they're trying to do, naturally, is the accounting trick of paying for lack of progress by disadvantaged kids with the inevitable progress of privileged kids. They're trying to obscure their inability to teach effectively by throwing in the racial component. It's bullshit, and people are right be outraged by it, and the administrators responsible for it should be made to pay for it.
- anigbrowl 14y agoNo, they don't necessarily have that information. It's not available for either first-graders, and not reliable for transfer students without knowledge of the standards employed at the previous school. What they're trying to do, naturally, is the accounting trick of paying for lack of progress by disadvantaged kids with the inevitable progress of privileged kids. That's a completely illogical argument. If that was their goal, it would be more sensible to ignore race and just aggregate the numbers together so that failing students would become invisible. Breaking results out by race highlights any differences in achievement over the measurement period.
- fusiongyro 14y agoYou need two data points to measure progress. First graders are the first data point. Transfer students alone are not a dominating element of the population. Pointing to an inability to get reliable test results from other districts is trying to excuse failure with more failure. The accounting trick works because it's about comparing percentages rather than raw numbers. The preponderance of disadvantaged kids would swamp the progress of the privileged kids otherwise. This trick lets them point to substantial performance improvements in substantially less than half their students and use it to write off the lack of progress on substantially more than half.
- danielweber 14y agoI think "number of kids who get free school lunch" is the most common measure of economic status. It's rough, but it's something.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat's a good point that I didn't think of, and would certainly be worth using. As pointed out elsewhere in this thread, though, race affects test cores even more than socioeconomic status.
- schoper 14y agoUnfortunately, socioeconomic status doesn't work. Poor white kids, for example, have this bad habit of out-scoring black children from the highest income brackets on the SATs. This is the same reason that AA-preferences in college admissions use race instead of SES.
- tedivm 14y agoThat's an interesting comment. I would be interested in seeing a source for that information, as opposed to just taking it at face value.
- hammock 14y agoHere is one example, from the California Department of Education: http://www.google.com/imgres?um=1&hl=en&safe=off&tbo=d&biw=1280&bih=657&tbm=isch&tbnid=UzNsFy3V9tzlLM:&imgrefurl=http://toped.svefoundation.org/2012/04/03/steming-the-minority-gap/&docid=37ve0tStuaFtZM&imgurl=http://toped.svefoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Achieve-RaceIncomeLPFIstudy032812.png&w=968&h=458&ei=V5uiUPC8I6mEygGV0IC4Dw&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=211&vpy=173&dur=590&hovh=154&hovw=327&tx=231&ty=170&sig=108167084116963101507&page=1&tbnh=133&tbnw=282&start=0&ndsp=18&ved=1t:429,r:1,s:0,i:75 http://www.google.com/imgres?um=1&hl=en&safe=off&...
- jessriedel 14y ago> Poor white kids, for example, have this bad habit of out-scoring black children from the highest income brackets on the SATs Wow, I didn't believe this until I looked it up. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2999198 http://www.jstor.org/stable/2999198 > In 1997, black students from families with incomes between $80,000 and $100,000 did in fact score lower on the SAT test than did students from white families with income less than $10,000.
- aqme28 14y agoWhy can't we measure a student's progress longitudinally? It can't be a cost problem. A student's improvement should be measured based on that student's previous level, not the level of that student's race. edit: Basically, wouldn't it be both smart and possible to keep track of a student's education records just like we do with a person's medical records?
- portmanteaufu 14y agoNow I'm depressed about the sad state of medical records too. :(
- twoodfin 14y agoWe can. This was, if I'm not mistaken, the fundamental idea behind NCLB. Schools had been hiding behind average test scores that obscured the fact that some kids were excelling while others were being shuffled along. So you test every student and grade schools on the absolute fraction that are hitting desired progress toward grade-level competency, not on averages or relative rates for different subgroups. But schools and teachers hated the added testing, and hated being labeled as "failing" when they failed to get a substantial fraction of their students up to grade level. Parents hated their schools being labeled "failing" (and feared the corresponding property value hit) while their children were doing just fine. So now we have waivers from NCLB and we're unsurprisingly back to the "soft bigotry of low expectations". Sorry to sound cynical about this. Really, I wish the Federal government would get out of the local education business entirely, besides making sure civil rights aren't being violated. But if they're going to be involved, they should be pushing for exactly the kind of student-by-student accountability that NCLB (no doubt with many imperfections) tried to impose.
- rayiner 14y ago> Sorry to sound cynical about this. Really, I wish the Federal government would get out of the local education business entirely, besides making sure civil rights aren't being violated. But if they're going to be involved, they should be pushing for exactly the kind of student-by-student accountability that NCLB (no doubt with many imperfections) tried to impose. The reason the federal government is involved in local education is that states do a terrible job of delivering uniformity in educational quality. White flight in the 1960's left urban school districts like Chicago as 85%+ low income and 90%+ black/hispanic. These school districts just don't have the property taxing power that homogenous suburban school districts have, and the federal government comes in to make up the difference.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoI don't really understand why they need to do it on a group basis at all. It's easy enough to put each student in a database at the very beginning and say, "the school should provide a net improvement of N% for each student." There is no reason to set a target for a group as a whole when technology allows us to track individuals just as easily.
- Jabbles 14y agoNot if by performance you mean "in comparison to everyone else". In that case education is zero-sum. If you measure to an absolute standard it may be easier, but education goals move all the time, and calibrating between them leaves these metrics open to statistical abuse, just like we're seeing here.
- stevesearer 14y agoThis is my thinking as well. When I was teaching and had students which performed below our expected outcomes, we didn't sit around and ponder their ethnicity or socioeconomic status, we simply worked hard to figure out how best to get that particular student caught up (or closer to their peers than before). In my estimation, the best way to break away from this ridiculous tendency to group people it to treat everyone like an individual.
- anigbrowl 14y agoWhat did you do if you found that large numbers of your underperforming students had some factor in common?
- jamesaguilar 14y agoYou'd probably study the factor and how to address it. But you wouldn't set targets for individuals who share the factor collectively.
- gte910h 14y agoFlorida is doing something similarly horrible.
- pc86 14y agoI think it would be more horrible to expect everyone to get 85 regardless of whether they're starting at 82 or 52.
- gte910h 14y agoIf you're talking about building standards off of individual students past behavior, I'm listening. Creating tranches by how brown kids are is stupid if not racist.
- jwoah12 14y agoIt's most definitely both of those things.
- ori_b 14y agoI think it would be a good idea to expect everyone to learn the material and be evaluated on their ability. If someone does a better job, they should get a better grade. If people find it hard to do understand the material, the solution isn't to let them scrape by with less understanding. That's doing the students a disservice. Instead, we should be investigating why the students are doing poorly, and at least attempting to fix the root causes. Bring people up to the desired standards, don't drop the standards. I think it's horrible to think that just because someone started off behind, they're too incompetent to produce the same quality of work as another student that started off with an advantage.
- illuminate 14y ago"I think it's horrible to think that just because someone started off behind, they're too incompetent to produce the same quality of work as another student that started off with an advantage." People who start off behind tend to not spontaneously catch up. And yes, it is horrible. "incompetent" is a bit of a loaded term to describe their current levels of understanding, however.
- herbig 14y agoThe HN title, "Grading kids by race" is misleading. It's not grading kids by race, it's setting different passing rate goals for different minority groups. "Virginia's expectation is that all students, regardless of race or ethnicity, will correctly answer the same number of questions to pass the state tests."
- mikegioia 14y agoWhile I think this is interesting in that the state is trying something new (I didn't even know states could get waivers for no child left behind) I can't help but think this will have a negative impact on the kids. They're basically being told that because of their race they have a lower expectation. Regardless of what historic data says, is lowering expectations for certain minorities ever the right approach? This just sounds like treating a symptom.
- tedivm 14y agoThink about it in the other direction too- if you're an asian who isn't the best at math you're considered a failure for not getting consistant B+ and A grades.
- mc32 14y agoI think this should be judged on its merits (results and intent). In the end, is this system better able to track progress and lift academic competency for affected children? Arguably race isn't and should not be the best or even the preferred selection criterion. Maybe economics, entrance exam results, etc., should guide the classification and tracking, regardless of race.
- tokenadult 14y ago[After edit: the submission title has been changed to match the original article title, in accord with the Hacker News guidelines. This is an interesting article on an important issue.] On the underlying policy issue, of course it is a good idea to set high standards for all pupils in a public school system and to manage the system so that as many pupils as possible can meet those standards. One example of good practice in the charter school sector, serving mostly low-income minority students, is the work of the Uncommon Schools charter school network, http://www.uncommonschools.org/ http://www.uncommonschools.org/ where Doug Lemov's Teach Like a Champion principles have been carefully monitored for their effectiveness in boosting student learning. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/07/magazine/07Teachers-t.html http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/07/magazine/07Teachers-t.html http://www.josseybass.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-0470550473.html http://www.josseybass.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-0470... Economist Roland Fryer is convinced that improvements in classroom practice can do much to improve educational outcomes for the most disadvantaged learners in the United States. http://www.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/fryer/files/Fryer_Racial_Inequality.pdf http://www.economics.harvard.edu/faculty/fryer/files/Fryer_R... AFTER EDIT: A story from National Public Radio, "Struggle For Smarts? How Eastern And Western Cultures Tackle Learning" submitted to Hacker News by another participant yesterday http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4773019 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4773019 (alas without comments after not appearing on the front page in time) is a very good supplement on the idea of different teaching practices producing different learning outcomes. That article is based on a comparison of classroom teaching practices between the United States and east Asia. I have lived in one of the countries profiled in that story, and can confirm the general correctness of the facts reported in the story. I look forward to thoughtful discussion about the policy issues being brought up in this thread.
- firefoxman1 14y agoI attended Virginia schools from grades 4-12, and my particular school district decided it would be a good idea to have a "prestigious" grading scale (A=93-100, B=87-92, C=78-86, and so on). It seemed like a good idea at first: A public school system would be known for having "higher standards" than others. The problem? Colleges didn't give a damn what grading scale you used. Your GPA was the same as anyone's, which made it harder on every student without any real benefit. My question is what does this "achievement standard" do if the grading system stays the same? It doesn't really seem to affect anyone, except maybe takes another step toward eliminating "survival of the fittest"
- sachingulaya 14y agoMy college had the same idea. To 'boost' the program they made the average GPA 2.8. The result? About 60%(instead of the usual 50%) of the graduating class was automatically denied interviews at company's that had a 3.0 minimum GPA requirement.
- tomjen3 14y agoWell that seems simple enough to fix. The average GPA is now 4. Here, go to all the interviews you want.
- abduhl 14y agoSince when is a B the 50th percentile?
- sachingulaya 14y agoIt doesn't matter what a B 'is'. Students and hiring managers both know B's are worthless.
- hammock 14y agoThis is not exactly true. The best public schools (e.g. in Virginia, Thomas Jefferson High School for Science and Technology) will have a relationship with the admissions committees at the best colleges in the area and nationally. In these cases they really do know and care about how the grading system is applied. For good private schools, the effect can be even greater. This insight doesn't apply to all public schools, though. If you are a standout student in a terrible off-radar public school, you will have to work harder through other channels than the reputation of your school.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- uhwuggawuh 14y agoNo, affirmative action is this: when two candidates are approximately equally qualified but one was raised black in the inner city and the other white, then it's best practice to choose the black candidate.
- TheGateKeeper 14y agoSo racist. Got it.
- TheIronYuppie 14y agoNot to respond to a glib response, but the issue crops up when the minority population is underrepresented as part of the company/college/etc. So for Morehouse (for example, a historically black college in the US) the reverse might be true. There's lots of literature backing this up - when you have a MORE diverse population in your company/college/whatever, it performs by almost any measure you can come up with, better as a whole.
- thirdtruck 14y agoI would use more general qualifiers in place of those specific expressions of the problem: "When comparing two candidates of otherwise approximately equal qualification, apply historical socio-economic advantages/disadvantages as modifiers to get their probable scores in the absence of those modifiers, then re-evaluate accordingly." Compare it to testing two sets of children, one that was kept up all night and one that got to sleep after studying, and extrapolate writ-large. In a similar vein, we can't make useful assessments about alcoholism susceptibility in Native American populations without first accounting for all of the historical socio-economic pressures that would likely drive a disproportionate amount of any given population to drink.
- SiVal 14y agoNo, affirmative action is this: when a white candidate is only slightly better qualified than a black candidate, the black candidate should be preferred, even if the black candidate came from a wealthy home and the white candidate grew up poor.
- patrickgzill 14y agoPresident Bush may or may not have been an idiot, but his speechwriter coined a useful phrase, "the soft bigotry of low expectations".
- arkclark 14y agoIf I understand this correctly, they're not saying asian students have to score almost twice as highly than black students. Instead, they're saying, "Okay, a majority of asians are passing our standards and proportionally fewer of black students are, so let's set those as a baseline and seek to improve from there." I find it questionable they would set the bar for what portion of students should pass state standards based on race, but if black students statistically struggle compared to asian students, I can see why they would do this.
- woodchuck64 14y agoPolicies like this are a result of ignoring good science in social cognition on the reality of stereotype threats. See for example http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2570773/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2570773/
- anigbrowl 14y agoBeing informed that you're attending a 'failing school' strikes me as just as much of a stereotype threat.