4 ms·
> It feels that Amazon and Starbucks (and probably Google) are straining credulity with their weird systems. They wouldn't do it if those were actually illegal
by jacques_chester 14y ago
> It feels that Amazon and Starbucks (and probably Google) are straining credulity with their weird systems.
They wouldn't do it if those were actually illegal systems of tax minimisation.
That you or I would like massively profitable companies to pay more tax in our respective countries is one matter. Whether they are obliged to do so by law is a different.
- Nursie 14y agoCertainly, but that's very, very different to the question of morality that you asked.
- jacques_chester 14y agoBut it's not, at all. The question I'm raising is: if I am obliged by law to pay X, is it moral that I pay only and exactly X?
- DanBC 14y agoIt is immoral if you evade the intent of the law by exploiting dubious loopholes such that you reduce the amount of tax you should pay beyond any reasonable lower limit to almost zero. Starbucks needing to pay Starbucks so that they can use the Starbucks brand (and thus - co-incidentally we're told) syphoning off profit from Starbucks UK to Starbucks cupboard in tax haven is an example of something that might be legally correct but is morally wrong. I think it's pretty clear that we disagree, so feel free to have the last word.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> the intent of the law The intent of tax law is everywhere the same: maximise revenue. Full stop. In the USA, the UK and Australia we live in a society of laws, not a society of personal judicial discretion. Judges give regard to the intent of the lawmakers insofar as it illuminates how to apply a piece of legislation. It is not their job to simply decide that something is "right" or "wrong" according to their personal views of what is a sensible policy setting for taxation. The point is that if you take the view that minimising tax is wrong, you need to explain why. The logical contrapositive (or is it converse? I always get them mixed up) is that maximising the tax you pay is morally correct, which opens up an embarrassing slippery slope argument that even I, as a recovering libertard, am not keen to go a-whooshing down. It is always important in discussion moral questions to distinguish between what is moral conduct and what are desirable outcomes. What humans do and what humans intend to come about are frequently very different, but we all have a habit of smooshing them together in discussions such as these. I realise that I have tremendously muddied the waters by insisting on reverting to first principles, but well ... principles matter. If I may create a false dichotomy: given the choice between a government of laws and a government with maximised revenue, I would prefer to live under a government of laws.
- DanBC 14y agoOkay, I think I understand a bit more about our disagreement. I don't care what the courts think. I agree with you - the law exists; judges interpret that law; these companies don't appear to be breaking any laws. My accusations of them not being moral isn't based in law, nor in them trying to reduce their tax bill. I think it's fine for people to reduce their tax burden. I even think it's fine for people to employ lawyers to scour the laws and find vigorous ways to reduce their tax burdens. But then there are tricks that are legal now, but which appear to flaunt the intent of the law, and which will get fixed at a later point. And, in my opinion, sometimes these tricks go so far as to be dishonest. And that's the bit where morality comes in. Companies that reduce their tax bills are not immoral, unless they are telling borderline lies in order to do so. When a UK company sells goods in the UK to UK citizens, making over £3bn per year in sales, and then say that their company is actually in Luxembourg and the UK business is just a delivery business to reduce their tax bill - well, that feels slimy. It might be legal. Some behaviour is not illegal, but that doesn't mean it's acceptable. The other thing about laws is that they are not fixed. They get refined over the years. And there are some grey areas until the law is tested by whoever enforces it.
- DanBC 14y ago> They wouldn't do it if those were actually illegal systems of tax minimisation. A remarkably naive view of corporations.
- jacques_chester 14y agoA remarkably naive view of humans, actually :D My point being that from the perspective of pure greed, breaking tax laws is dumb. The IRS, HMRC, the ATO and their ilk all have amazing powers to obtain compliance from taxpayers. But only up to the boundaries of the law. Which is why the smart thing to do is to ... work up to the boundaries of the law.
- Nursie 14y agoMorality and unmitigated self interest are not always totally aligned. WEIRD HUH?
- Gormo 14y agoCorporations are abstractions. Governments are abstractions. Society is, substantively, nothing but people. If we admit that some people are willing to pursue their particular ambitions by abusing other people, it behooves us to restrain their capacity for damage, no matter what conceptual abstraction they're using as the instrument of their abuse. Corporations and governments are fundamentally the same thing - groups of people - and aiming to shrink the power of one by giving even greater power to the other is no solution at all.