4 ms·
"No man in the country is under the smallest obligation, moral or other, so to arrange his legal relations to his business or property as to enable the Inland R
by jacques_chester 14y ago
"No man in the country is under the smallest obligation, moral or other, so to arrange his legal relations to his business or property as to enable the Inland Revenue to put the largest possible shovel in his stores. The Inland Revenue is not slow, and quite rightly, to take every advantage which is open to it under the Taxing Statutes for the purposes of depleting the taxpayer's pocket. And the taxpayer is in like manner entitled to be astute to prevent, so far as he honestly can, the depletion of his means by the Inland Revenue"
Ayrshire Pullman Motor Services v Inland Revenue [1929] 141 Tax Case 754.
"Anyone may arrange his affairs so that his taxes shall be as low as possible; he is not bound to choose that pattern which best pays the treasury. There is not even a patriotic duty to increase one's taxes. Over and over again the Courts have said that there is nothing sinister in so arranging affairs as to keep taxes as low as possible. Everyone does it, rich and poor alike and all do right, for nobody owes any public duty to pay more than the law demands."
Gregory v. Helvering 69 F.2d 809, 810 (2d Cir. 1934), aff'd, 293 U.S. 465, 55 S.Ct. 266, 79 L.Ed. 596 (1935)
- dabeeeenster 14y agoI don't think anyone is arguing against these sentiments, it's more a question of upholding the spirit rather than the letter of the law. I doubt much 1930's money was being filtered through Bermudan or Lichtensteinien shell companies.
- jacques_chester 14y agoInternational commerce is not new, and the common law principle that the taxpayer is not obliged to maximise their tax bill is exactly the same and has been upheld consistently for centuries. Countries who want to make money via a territorial nexus usually use VAT or GST ... which the UK already does.
- spindritf 14y ago> Countries who want to make money via a territorial nexus usually use VAT or GST Exactly, they have run into fundamental problems with income tax which is simply a bad tax scheme. From being counterproductive to easy to game (at a certain scale).
- jacques_chester 14y agoGSTs and VATs do "leak" for customers who personally import goods or services. So for example, Amazon collects no GST for the Australian Tax Office when I import books from them. On the other hand, I receive no ability to offset my own GST collections against GST expenditures. Every tax has problems. That's why every major economy has a bunch of different taxes that collect money in different ways for different kinds of economic events -- purchases, income, sale of capital/equity and so on.
- arethuza 14y agoThe Vestey brothers pioneered using offshore trusts for tax evasion in the 1920s: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Vestey,_1st_Baron_Vestey http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Vestey,_1st_Baron_Veste...
- spindritf 14y agoTax avoidance. It was legal.
- r3m6 14y agoFirst, I wonder if you would quote the same sources if Amazon, Google,Starbucks would move the money from the USA to Europe and not the other way around. Second, everyone knows that this "sorry, we have to pay royalties" thing is most likely legal, but a very grey area. It certainly is against the spirit of the law. A company whose main product is "we make you feel good" should not use such tactics in their own interest.
- bruceboughton 14y agoHe quoted US case law as well as UK precedent. Of course he would argue the same thing the other way round.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI'm actually Australian.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> It certainly is against the spirit of the law. No judge will ever make a ruling on the basis of "the spirit of the law". They may try to divine the intent of Parliament or Congress according to agreed interpretive rules. But it's still about rules. Predictable, and precise. Even the law of Equity, which is the closest to being the law that is about the "spirit" of the law ... relies on rules. Otherwise you no longer have a government of law, you have a government of men. Those don't work very well.
- Gormo 14y agoOf course, if men are making the rules in the first place, you no closer to having a government of law. The closest we can come to having a true government of law is for the process that generates law to be rooted entirely in natural law theory, where the law is "discovered" instead of created. Common law and equity are at least traditionally an attempt at this, but any system that makes room for positive law, or contains any sort of legislative institution, can't even be described as an attempt at a government of law.
- mfringel 14y agoSeeing the Judge Learned Hand quote taken out of context is a pet peeve, mostly because it happens so damn often. Your latter quote is actually from Helvering v. Gregory, which was the 2nd Circuit case. Here's a quote from the case actually named Gregory v. Helvering, which was the SCOTUS case[1]: "In these circumstances, the facts speak for themselves, and are susceptible of but one interpretation. The whole undertaking, though conducted according to the terms of subdivision (B), was in fact an elaborate and devious form of conveyance masquerading as a corporate reorganization, and nothing else. The rule which excludes from consideration the motive of tax avoidance is not pertinent to the situation, because the transaction, upon its face, lies outside the plain intent of the statute. To hold otherwise would be to exalt artifice above reality and to deprive the statutory provision in question of all serious purpose. Judgment affirmed." In short, business transactions must have a business purpose, and the substance of the transaction is much more important than the form. [1] http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/293/465/case.html http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/293/465/case.html
- jacques_chester 14y agoIt's quoted "out of context" because it is generally considered to be a persuasive obiter dictum. And that's how law quotes work. Sometimes the facts of the case bear on obiter dicta. Sometimes they don't. That doesn't change their degree of persuasiveness.
- mfringel 14y agoI have never found the Learned Hand quote persuasive specifically because I know the context.
- jacques_chester 14y agoThe context doesn't change the principle. At all. That case was about a party who didn't exploit the fully legal options. Every single day judgements are written where a principle is outlined and then, when the principle has been breached, the judge says so. Does that change the principle? No. Because it is the principle. Certain obiter dicta are taken as "persuasive" by other courts because they form such a concise statement of a legal principle that they can't really be improved on. The two quotes I gave above are widely used in tax law in multiple countries because they elegantly state the general principle that a taxpayer has no legal obligation to help the tax man raise more money.
- shardling 14y agoI'd say that you do have a moral obligation to pay taxes, regardless of the legal facts.
- jacques_chester 14y agoWhy?
- shardling 14y agoTo support the very civilization you benefit from.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI get it, necessary evil, all that jazz. But the question is not: Should taxes be levied? It is: Is it immoral to pay only what the law requires?
- Nursie 14y agoI would say: That depends on how hard you're trying to work around it. If you're shifting profits around the globe deliberately to avoid taxes in the places you generated those profits - yes. Other people will draw the line in different places, as demonstrated by the comments here!
- jacques_chester 14y agoEvery purchase I can justifiably put through my Pty Ltd company, I do so, to minimise the amount of tax I pay. Is that categorically different?
- Nursie 14y agoIMHO, yes. I'm in a similar situation. Things the company needs (justifiably) the company buys. I consider it very different to using accounting tricks to make profits disappear out of the country entirely, based on bogus internal charging.
- gadders 14y agoAbsolutely. It just annoys me that in the same way as the UK Police target the mostly-law abiding (motorists, for instance) as they're easier to prosecute. HMRC is scared to tackle large companies but is ruthless when it comes to small ones.