3 ms·
It's an interesting conflict, and clearly they do have a duty to investors to maximise their profit. If it was a privately owned company it might be more clear
by Nursie 14y ago
It's an interesting conflict, and clearly they do have a duty to investors to maximise their profit. If it was a privately owned company it might be more clear cut.
Absolutely agree the laws need to be changed. I, personally, would be looking to stop the 'convenient' reporting of losses in markets that are actually highly profitable but not tax efficient. There's an interesting comment on the Starbucks press release that coves it quite nicely -
"How can Starbucks tell Companies House and HMRC that its UK business is loss-making but tell analysts in SEC-regulated calls that the UK business is profit-making, without either making misleading financial statements or filing false accounts?"
- rfugger 14y agohttp://starbucks.co.uk/blog/starbucks-commitment-to-the-uk/1240 http://starbucks.co.uk/blog/starbucks-commitment-to-the-uk/1...
- smoyer 14y agoYou'd think these companies would be smart enough to show a small profit and pay the taxes on it ... You don't really gain anything by showing a loss.
- arethuza 14y agoThey aren't the same legal entity - it is entirely possible that the US parent company is profitable and the UK subsidiary loss making (or indeed vice-versa).
- Nursie 14y agoThat's not what's happening though, there are reports by the parent company that the UK business is profitable, when it suits them to boost share prices, yet reports from in country that there has been a loss so they can minimise taxes. I agree - it's possible that Starbucks UK is not pofitable, and that the parent company is, or vice versa. But reporting the same thing in different ways to different audiences seems fishy to me!
- arethuza 14y agoGood point - I guess if they are saying in their UK tax return that they aren't profitable and the US reports that they are making substantial profits in the UK then that is extremely fishy. Aren't they just transfer pricing their profits out of the UK to Switzerland and the US?