6 ms·
The 'Hollywood Accounting' that goes on in these multinationals is quite spectacular. Moving cash around between their various subsidiaries and national compani
by Nursie 14y ago
The 'Hollywood Accounting' that goes on in these multinationals is quite spectacular. Moving cash around between their various subsidiaries and national companies in such a way as to pay the least possible tax and to make strategic losses where convenient, all the while announcing record profits.
I can see why you would try it on, the sums involved have to be huge, but it is fundamentally immoral to operate like that.
- easytiger 14y ago> fundamentally immoral to operate like that. err. no it isn't.
- Nursie 14y agoIt is in my moral code - Availing yourself of a market and using the facilities and workforce of the UK, without chipping in your fair share (as decided by the people of that country). Sounds immoral to me.
- Jach 14y agoI'm sure if the UK precisely defined what they mean by "fair share", and enforced their own laws regarding companies paying their "fair share", these companies would pay it. Or leave and do business elsewhere. Trying to do business without paying the legally required tax would be illegal, and immoral in your system, but not immoral in any system that views forms of income taxes as evil. (There are a lot of those around.)
- Nursie 14y agoThere are indeed a lot of people who view income taxes as evil. Many, many people including a lot of people in the UK. But that doesn't stop them being thought of as a necessary evil, and avoidance as worse. It's quite clear what the intent of the tax laws is, and it's quite clear that announcing a loss to the tax office but a massive profit to your investors is at the very least duplicitous.
- easytiger 14y ago> It's quite clear what the intent of the tax laws is, If it was then what they are doing would be illegal
- Nursie 14y agoSo in your mind there's never a loophole in a law or a conflict between the law as intended and the law as written or enacted by the courts? Interesting worldview there...
- easytiger 14y agotax is a robbery anyway. We only pay it because the government will take away our personal freedoms if they didn't receive payment. Do you honestly think if tax was 100% voluntary people would willingly donate without being coerced into doing it?
- CompiledCode 14y agoI agree. It's stunning to me that a bunch of executives and lawyers sat together and decided, we are going to take advantage of the infrastructure and workforce in the UK, but will avoid paying any taxes there, using these clever shenanigans. And because it saves money and is in the interest of the company, it's okay. That most ordinary people would agree that this is the right approach tells volumes about the society we live in.
- easytiger 14y ago> It is in my moral code Someone out there has a moral code that encourages stoning women to death. Doesn't mean that has got anything to do with anything being as it is a vague and meaningless concept that doesn't inform governance. > Availing yourself of a market By which you mean acting as a VAT collection body and sending that money to the treasury for transactions within that market that occured under your business. > the facilities and workforce of the UK Would you rather the roads were empty because the people of the UK had no jobs? There are ways to address this issue as discussed endlessly. But the last thing this is is immoral. It may not be just nor fair, but those do no interact with the morality of a benign government and their laws and regulations. It doesn't help the argument but it is rhetoric that is being thrown around that as much as anything hinders progress on this issue
- Nursie 14y agoSomeone out there has a moral code... I didn't claim morality was objective, no need to behave as if I did. By which you mean acting as a VAT collection body... What are you trying to say here? That because they collect VAT that's ok and they should be exempt from other taxes? Would you rather the roads were empty because the people of the UK had no jobs? False dichotomy. It's not the ability to move profits abroad that keeps people employed in the UK, arguably it sucks money out of the country and is a net loss to our economy.
- burke 14y ago> I didn't claim morality was objective, no need to behave as if I did. > it is fundamentally immoral to operate like that. Sounds pretty objectively-stated to me. Count me in the camp that disagrees with you. Normal people do all sorts of perfectly legal tricks to pay less income tax. They're not cheating; they're just paying the minimum they're legally required to pay. Same deal for business. Whatever they can get away with without breaking any laws is the minimum requirement. Paying extra tax out of some patriotic duty is illogical, as is not taking advantage of the perfectly-legal loopholes found. It is not up to the businesses to pay more tax than the current legal framework requires; it's up to lawmakers to amend the tax code so that 'undesirable' loopholes are closed. Businesses act to maximize profits. There is nothing immoral about this.
- mtrimpe 14y agoIt's not fundamentally immoral; it's more of a tragedy of the commons. All these loopholes are perfectly legal and companies actually need to exploit them to remain competitive.If they didn't then any competitor could decide to do this and could earn 30% less and still make a bigger profit. It would of course have been great if the representatives had been self-aware enough to agree that they might not be taxed effectively in a global market and that they would be willing to co-operate with aligning global tax incentives in a way that leaves it a level playing field for all competitors; but that's probably a bit much to ask ;)
- Nursie 14y agoWhether it's a tragedy of the commons or not is orthogonal (IMHO) to a question of morality. Same with legality. I don't disagree with what you're saying otherwise.
- davidp 14y agoIt's better to treat matters of law as orthogonal to matters of morality, since the latter depends very much on the subjective judgment of the observer. Example: A company, acting "morally" as you define, pays more tax than it is required to under the law. In so doing, it incurs a loss so severe that it must cut staff in order to remain viable. Among those employees cut are some of the more vulnerable - those with low savings, poor health, or babies on the way. Has the company acted morally? Consider another issue: Should the same company pay more than its legal obligations in every jurisdiction to which it is subject? How should it allocate its extra giving? What if, in some of those jurisdictions, there's a good chance the extra money will simply go into private pockets via graft and corruption, instead of serving the public good? (There are such jurisdictions in the EU, yes?) These issues are not as clear-cut as you suggest. It's far better for the tax law to best reflect the morality of the citizenry, and then fully excuse the citizenry (including business entities) from seeking to legally minimize those taxes.
- mercurial 14y agoThat's disingenuous. You make it sound like your imaginary company goes to extra length to "pay more tax than is required under the law" while it's the complete opposite: these companies go the extra mile to game the system and pay a minimal amount of tax by exploiting failures in the system. There is no "extra giving" to consider, they should just be paying the same taxes other companies are paying.
- smoyer 14y ago"Fundamentally immoral" In the US a corporation's legal responsibilities are to it's shareholders ... it might be fundamentally immoral but it would be unethical to operate the company against the interests of the shareholders too. It's the laws that need to be changed rather than blaming the companies for being good at accounting.
- Nursie 14y agoIt's an interesting conflict, and clearly they do have a duty to investors to maximise their profit. If it was a privately owned company it might be more clear cut. Absolutely agree the laws need to be changed. I, personally, would be looking to stop the 'convenient' reporting of losses in markets that are actually highly profitable but not tax efficient. There's an interesting comment on the Starbucks press release that coves it quite nicely - "How can Starbucks tell Companies House and HMRC that its UK business is loss-making but tell analysts in SEC-regulated calls that the UK business is profit-making, without either making misleading financial statements or filing false accounts?"
- rfugger 14y agohttp://starbucks.co.uk/blog/starbucks-commitment-to-the-uk/1240 http://starbucks.co.uk/blog/starbucks-commitment-to-the-uk/1...
- smoyer 14y agoYou'd think these companies would be smart enough to show a small profit and pay the taxes on it ... You don't really gain anything by showing a loss.
- arethuza 14y agoThey aren't the same legal entity - it is entirely possible that the US parent company is profitable and the UK subsidiary loss making (or indeed vice-versa).
- Nursie 14y agoThat's not what's happening though, there are reports by the parent company that the UK business is profitable, when it suits them to boost share prices, yet reports from in country that there has been a loss so they can minimise taxes. I agree - it's possible that Starbucks UK is not pofitable, and that the parent company is, or vice versa. But reporting the same thing in different ways to different audiences seems fishy to me!
- appleflaxen 14y agoThe question of immorality is irrelevant unless it is also illegal. It is the government's fault for putting so many loopholes in the tax code. They knew exactly what they were doing when they put them there, and have just as much culpability as Amazon, Google, and Starbucks.
- buro9 14y agoI'm not sure the law cares about morals. I do think though, that US law dictates that they must work for shareholder value. It's hard to see how we wouldn't end up here if they aren't actually breaking any laws on their way to this destination.
- _delirium 14y agoThat's actually a bit of a myth; companies don't have any explicit legal obligation to maximize shareholder value. In addition, courts tend to defer to their judgment on things such as intangibles; if a company says they're doing X because it's good for the company's image even though it loses money in the short term, a court will generally not second-guess that decision, especially since the shareholders have alternate means to reverse it if they disagree, such as voting out the board. To the extent the shareholders keep the board in place, they're presumed to agree with their decisions on where to take the company. The material that makes for a successful shareholder lawsuit tends to be more about things like favoring one class of shareholders over another, or executives making decisions for their personal gain. Earlier HN discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3227980 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3227980
- brudgers 14y agoBusinesses are neither immoral nor moral. They are amoral.
- Nursie 14y agoThey are. I don't think this is good though. Companies are made up of people, and these people are the ones taking the actions.
- brudgers 14y agoThese companies are based upon the proposition that the people who own them are not accountable for what the company does. Furthermore, to a large extent the people who operate the company are largely absolved for their actions. Corporations, like Nicheian supermen, are not subject to ordinary rules. If you were dodging taxes, your ass would be in court, not before parliament.
- bmelton 14y agoI would think of it more like 'couponing' than cheating the system. The companies in question are availing themselves of the laws available to them to get discounts on their tax obligation, just as an individual might claim their children as tax exemptions, and use charity contributions as write-offs. As you indicated elsewhere, morals and law do not necessarily align, and you are trying to attach morality to a legal obligation here. That companies do the same thing as everybody else does shouldn't be counted against them, especially as it is legal.