4 ms·

> metal detectors are kind of the primary way we try to find guns on people What are bullets and shell casings made out of again?

• Kirby64 6mo ago
  More importantly, what is the barrel made out of? Yes, I know there’s some fully printed guns… but my understanding is that those are basically 1-time use and even then it’s questionable how reliable that single use actually is… If you want something resembling an actual gun (more than one shot, won’t blow up in your hand, some reasonable chance of accuracy, etc), then you’re going to be using multiple metal components (including the bullets of course) all of which would show up on a metal detector.
• captaincrisp 6mo ago
  And importantly the barrel. Plastic cannot contain the pressure required to fire a bullet.
• trollbridge 6mo ago
  And I'd argue that shell casings are probably harder to manufacture than a fully working firearm. The equipment needed to manufacture working ammunition end-to-end is pretty serious.
  • 15155 6mo ago
    All of these manufacturing equipment and processes existed more than a century ago. If you have a capable VMC, you can make the die and other equipment necessary to stamp shell casings from commonly-available parts and machinery. From there, with a modern Dillon or Hornady reloading press, you can crank out thousands of rounds per day without issue. Primers are a legitimately difficult thing to manufacture, but (good-enough) bullets, casings, etc. are completely doable.
    • rolph 6mo ago
      [Primers are a legitimately difficult thing to manufacture] thats a problem that may not endure. if a firearm is reengineered to use an electrode to detonate charge rather than a chemical primer, there is no need for murcury fulminate, just a piezo electric spark generator, and a few square cm of cerebral cortex.
      • jandrewrogers 6mo ago
        Electronic primers are a thing that already exists commercially. In the early 2000s, Remington sold electronically primed hunting rifles next to their non-electronic equivalent (see: "EtronX"). It is a mature technology. The main issue is cost and simplicity, since it often requires adding electronics to weapons that normally would not require them. The military uses electronically primed cartridges for things like chain guns and autocannons, since those require electronics to fire regardless of how it is primed.
        • rolph 6mo ago
          yes ive seen them they are called exotic by most people around me. yes the very nature of a chain cannon, makes electronic priming,the easier way to go. so far we can still go to the store with 20$ and come back with a 200pk of 209s, someday that might be not so easy, and electronic is the better/only way.
        • Teever 6mo ago
          What advantage do they have over chemical primers?
          • rolph 6mo ago
            mechanical parts only move so fast, heat up and wear. when you have a chain cannon rof 100 rnds per second, it gets intense. a spark discharge solves a lot of kinetic issues with engineering the mechanism and its timing.
          • jandrewrogers 6mo ago
            It completely eliminates the physics and durability considerations of firing pin design. For chemical primers there is a non-trivial lag between the trigger breaking and the firing pin being accelerated to sufficient velocity such that it ignites the primer. The mechanics of maximizing acceleration of the firing pin is adversarial to durability, reliability, and precision in a number of respects. In automatic weapons it is made worse because the same physics must run in reverse to support the desired rate of fire. With electronic primers, you mostly only need to worry about switching electric power fast enough (trivial). The relatively fragile firing pin mechanics don't need to exist. But you do need electronics, which has its own issues.
    • trollbridge 6mo ago
      I have no ability to make primers specifically, and wouldn’t even know where to start.
    • dghlsakjg 6mo ago
      Imagine a flintlock 3d printed gun with hand cast lead balls: watch out redcoats!
• michaelt 6mo ago
  In the movies, you hide the bullets in a pen or something, and it bypasses the metal detector along with the keys, phones and watches.
  • ancientorange 6mo ago
    rabbits' foot, iIrc.
• esseph 6mo ago
  > What are bullets and shell casings made out of again? Usually non-ferrous metals like brass, lead, and copper unless you live closer to Russia, then you may end up with steel-case. That's besides the point though, the barrel of the gun will be steel.
  • 15155 6mo ago
    Ferrous metals aren't required for any modern security-screening metal detectors: these materials are still highly electrically conductive, and therefore easily-detectable eddy currents are still inducible.
    • esseph 6mo ago
      Oh, that's right! I remember reading somewhere about this a few years back. Might have even been here on HN. For some reason I hear "metal detector" and my brain goes right to magnetism.