4 ms·
When it comes to distracted driving, is talking to a passenger in the car any different than talking on the phone on a hands-free device? Is there something wei
by majormajor 14y ago
When it comes to distracted driving, is talking to a passenger in the car any different than talking on the phone on a hands-free device? Is there something weird going on in the brain when it comes to having a conversation with someone not physically present?
- jsyedidia 14y agoYes. The passenger in the car sitting next to you senses when something tricky is happening with the driving and shuts up or otherwise calls your attention to the danger. Someone conversing with you on the phone doesn't. Kids talking to you from the back seat are also a potentially more dangerous distraction for the same reason.
- kgermino 14y agoI have seen (although I can't remember where so this might not be worth much) that the freequency clipping cell phones do for compression can make it harder for you to processes what you're being told on a phone. Put a better way, cell carriers clip the upper and lower ranges of the audible spectrum. While your voice won't get completely cut, sometimes you lose information the brain uses to process language. Without this, you need to work harder to understand what you're being told than you would if you were talking to someone next to you.
- redler 14y agoOne theory is that, yes, something different is going on in the brain when speaking on a phone, as opposed to speaking with a passenger. "It may be that talking on the phone generates mental images that conflict with the spatial processing needed for safe driving. Eye-tracking studies show that while drivers continually look side to side, cellphone users tend to stare straight ahead. "They may also be distracted to the point that their engaged brains no longer process much of the information that falls on their retinas, which leads to slower reaction times and other driving problems. -- New York Times, "A Problem of the Brain, Not the Hands: Group Urges Phone Ban for Drivers" [0] [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/13/health/13well.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/13/health/13well.html?_r=0 Edit: clarity.
- majormajor 14y agoInteresting. They eye tracking stuff is especially fascinating.