3 ms·
The punditry have learned nothing. Help America Vote Act (HAVA) ushered in the touchscreens in a massive turf grab. Insecure, unreliable, untested touch screen
by specialist 14y ago
The punditry have learned nothing.
Help America Vote Act (HAVA) ushered in the touchscreens in a massive turf grab. Insecure, unreliable, untested touch screens were rushed to market.
The same forces are now at work pushing vote by mail and then electronic balloting.
For the vendors, is about charging for the upgrade and switchover costs. Anything to make a buck.
Election integrity is barely considered.
During the hearings to permit casting ballots VIA EMAIL in my state, a retired general now lobbying for the vendors claimed "internet security has gotten really good." Well, shit, if a general says it's cool, that's good enough for me. Bill sailed through legislature unanimously. Because its for the children, err, troops.
I talked to many of the legislators about electronic voting and casting ballots via the internet. First, they didn't understand that email was delivered via the internet in the clear. Second, if you're explaining, you're losing. Meaning once you start talking policy, their eyes glaze over, oops, sorry, your five minutes are up. Next!
The only way the legislators vote against this stuff is if they feel the heat. Meaning stuff the hearings and their inboxes with opposition.
I could go on and on, but I have pancakes waiting for me.
- dmckeon 14y agoOn-line voting is not impossible, but people tend to see the "I marked my ballot" part and ignore the rest of the voting ecosystem. Registering voters implies maintaining a registration DB, and handling moves, deaths, changes of name, changes of civil status that may disenfranchise or re-enfranchise a voter. Preparing ballots, paper or otherwise, implies matching voters to the appropriate ballot, precinct, or voting center. Avoiding or invalidating multi-voting (in the same jurisdiction) implies knowing whether a voter has or has not voted, and keeping them from voting multiple times. Counting paper ballots implies accounting for spoiled and unused ballots and dealing with faint or unintended marks. Secrecy of ballot implies that nobody else knows or can find out how a voter actually voted (currently unless they show someone a mail-in ballot before mailing it.) Imagine the result of a smartphone app that wrapped around a voting app, and offered to pay voters $50 to vote for or against a candidate or ballot measure - even if the payoff app completely failed to work, just the purported existence of such a tool might cast doubt on a election result. Voting online is not a "greenfield" problem - it would have to subsume a lot of previous experience and knowledge before being thoroughly trusted by its users. I would suggest to anyone exploring online voting that they get a grassroots look at the current process - volunteer to be a elections clerk (judge, watcher, etc.) at your next local election, and/or become a voter registrar if your jurisdiction allows citizens to fill that role. If you'd rather just web-browse, I can recommend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avi_Rubin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avi_Rubin as a useful and thoughtful source. PS - my voting preference is that voters mark scannable ballots, that are scanned immediately in the voter's presence. You get the persistence of paper, immediate feedback for mismarks or unscannable ballots, and good reproducibility of count if needed. Also, if a surge of people arrives at a polling place, paper ballot marking can be done in parallel, rather than having a bottleneck of a few (expensive) machines that all voters must use (registration look-up and ballot scanning are still bottlenecks).
- specialist 14y ago> I would suggest to anyone exploring online voting that they get a grassroots look at the current process... Exactly. I've worked as poll judge, poll inspector, poll observer, central count observer. I have yet to work central count, but I have mean colleagues who have. When I got started on this issue, I had many many misconceptions about election administration. I mark my ballot, drop in the mail, it gets counted. What could be more simple? Now I know that central count and mail ballot processing is like making sausage. And that electronic voting requires a religious style belief that everything just works. > Secrecy of ballot implies... Voter privacy has traditionally meant before and after casting one's ballot. The "before" part is completely ignored by all the proposed online voting systems. Ditto postal balloting (vote by mail). The Australian Ballot system permits marking one's ballot in private and prevents linking that ballot to the voter during counting. It's the gold standard. We may divine something better. Until then, I'm sticking to what works. Like you imply, that's paper ballots cast at poll sites read by mark sense style optical scanners.