3 ms·
As always, security is intimately tied to economics. How many people are interested in breaking into the Estonian elections, versus how many are interested in g
by stcredzero 14y ago
As always, security is intimately tied to economics. How many people are interested in breaking into the Estonian elections, versus how many are interested in gaining power over the US elections? It's quite a stark contrast. This is why you can't lock your Ferrari in an rusty shed with a cheap master lock on it. (Though the shed will probably be excellent security for a 2nd hand bike.)
E-voting in Estonia is probably a good idea. E-voting in the US is a catastrophically bad one until we get trusted execution infrastructure as described in Vernor Vinge's sci-fi books. (Yes, that's DRM, but DRM in the hands of individuals is very different from DRM in the hands of governments and large corporations.)
EDIT: Right now, we don't need an ID to vote. That's because creating zombie voters isn't yet possible with paper technology, unless you game the counting, which has better security. Keeping such a conspiracy secret would be difficult, though. Gaming the system and getting away with it would be possible with e-voting machines. Given that only a few swing states need to be affected, organizations that can command 100's of millions of dollars could pull such a thing off.
- anewguy 14y agoIt's funny that you mention this. In most American states, you don't even need ID to vote. We take vote security much less seriously than other countries.
- gojomo 14y agoFYI to sibling responder 'anewguy': looks like your comments are going auto-dead... so many readers can't see, reply, or vote on them. See the guidelines (http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) to inquire about this status.
- rmc 14y agoHow many people are interested in breaking into the Estonian elections, versus how many are interested in gaining power over the US elections? You think there is no corruption or organised gangs or corrupt politicians in Estonia (or any other country)? Anywhere there is political office, someone'll want to scam their way in. Yes a small country can be less of a target, but they also need less votes to swing it, and have less money to protect against it.
- stcredzero 14y ago> You think there is no corruption or organised gangs or corrupt politicians in Estonia (or any other country)? Anywhere there is political office, someone'll want to scam their way in. I never said that. What I'm saying is that the potential payoff is much smaller. > Yes a small country can be less of a target, but they also need less votes to swing it, and have less money to protect against it. There's a big difference between the ROI on the control of Estonia vs. the ROI on control of the US. The ROI is geometrically greater in the second case, which means that Estonia can hope to afford to protect itself, whereas it's probably hopeless for the US.