4 ms·
32 gigabytes for 20 "high definition" movies? That's 1.6GB per movie. Seems awfully low, compared to eg Blu-Ray. Afaik movies on blurays are in the 20GB range,
by zokier 14y ago
32 gigabytes for 20 "high definition" movies? That's 1.6GB per movie. Seems awfully low, compared to eg Blu-Ray. Afaik movies on blurays are in the 20GB range, ie. an order of magnitude larger than the presented 1.6GB. Even movies downscaled to 720p are usually sized to fit a DVD5, 4.3 GB, still much larger than 1.6GB.
Point being that movie files are still quite huge.
Also, transferring 32GB over fairly modest 10Mbps line takes roughly 7 hours, far less time than what it'd take via post service.
- dexter313 14y agoI don't that cubans have many 10Mbps connections.
- icebraining 14y agoDue to the asymmetric nature of most end-user lines, 10Mbps of upload bandwidth seem far from modest. Around here you'd need a 100mbps (download) line, which is available but pricey, and as far as I know they're not even available in most of the world. If you're talking about countries where this censorship is common, even a 10/1 line is probably not affordable by anyone except an elite.
- edent 14y agoVery true. I'm on "Superfast" broadband in the UK. That means 16Mbps down, 1.3Mbps up. The only way to get 10Mbps up is to be on fibre-to-the-premises. And even then only if you live in one of the blessed areas.
- elemeno 14y agoADSL supports up to 24Mbps down in the UK - assuming that you're (very) close to the exchange. I could theoretically get that with my old ISP, were I not 1.6km from the exchange. Cable supports up to 100Mbs down (at least I'm pretty sure that Virgin has started to roll that out, if not then 50Mbs), though contention might be an issue at peak times. I've got BT Infinity, which is fibre to the cabinet rather than all the way to the home. Since the distance to the cabinet is likely to be pretty minimal you can get pretty high bandwidth over the last length of telephone wire. For reference, I get 76Mbs down and 20+Mbs up - more than fast enough for plently of thing to feel instant, such as downloading movies which now takes in the order of minutes.
- miahi 14y agoCable supports even more. I'm on a 150Mbps cable modem now and it's nice. Too bad the upload is limited to 6Mbps.
- electromagnetic 14y agoI think in censored countries, a 10/1 line is essentially non-censored. The only people who would be getting that are government officials or company executives who are in bed with the government. I think the premise of the article is flawed, because I have a 16/2 connection. I recently express mailed an envelope across country (GTA to Vancouver) and it took approximately 4 business days and cost me ~$12. To do this through the internet, we're looking at 1.5 days for my internet connection (assuming upload is the speed issue). Even at the average 10/1 connection, we're talking 3 days. Still beats mail, and god forbid you mail on a thursday and it takes 6-7 days to get the mail through. What about from Canada to Australia? Well an express letter, you're looking at 2 weeks if you're lucky. Remember, this is only a product of our lazy ISPs happy to keep service where it is whilst bumping up prices. If Google Fibre has an effect on the market this discussion is meaningless. Up to 1gbps up and down. This discussion is meaningless if it only attains 10mbps upload, it won't even leave the post office in the time it would take to transfer. The notion that SOPA et al will destroy the internet is a little absurd, all it will do is expand the darknet, which will cause rapid expansion. Think what Tor would be if every computer in the world was on it and acting as a proxy. This is what governments will force to happen with restrictive legislation and our "controlled freedom" will become uncontrollable freedom.
- optimo 14y agoDVD/Bluray typically use MPEG2- for the sake of discussion this is 'uncompressed' because studios don't make raw video data available. Many consumer videos are transcoded into a more compact MP4 format - of course you need a specialized device or a PC to watch MP4. Most media players nowadays can support mp4 decoding, however. It's not the same quality as mpeg2, but passable to the casual viewing audience, mp4 uses predictive motion encoding, spatial and temporal compression, and reduced chroma sampling sometimes. Modern video streaming services now all probably use moderate-complexity mpeg4 encoding, resulting in a lower bandwidth. (movies rented from Apple, amazon, netflix, etc). A 1.6 Gbyte mp4 file is decent 720p depending on the scene contents and length of the video, at a fixed bitrate. edit: and it's worth noting that these small video files will typically strip the multi-channel audio and favor a remixed stereo-only sound track. saves more bytes. edit: kudos to poster below for clarifying my half-baked explanation.
- eigenvector 14y agoMP4 is a container format, MPEG2 is a compression algorithm. A variety of video and audio compression algorithms can be used inside the MP4 container although H.264 is probably the most common. DVD does use MPEG2. Blu-ray supports a variety of algorithms for video and audio with the BDAV container (.m2ts), commonly MPEG2, H.264 (AVC) and VC1 for video and DTS-HD MA, Dolby TrueHD and garden-variety LPCM for lossless audio. Today, most Blu-rays are being authored with H.264 or VC1 encoding for video. That being said, space savings are achieved by trans-coding the raw .m2ts to much lower bitrate H.264 and downmixing the audio to, say, 620kbps DD5.1 or even just stereo.
- Hupo 14y agoTo add to the clarification, both DVD and Blu-ray content is basically always sampled as YUV 4:2:0, and basically no transcode ever changes that. Masters generally have higher chroma sampling (eg. 4:2:2) but this is reduced to 4:2:0 when the content is put on DVD/BD, not by encoders further down the chain. Masters can also have a higher bit depth (eg. 10-bit) per channel which is then converted to 8-bit for DVD/BD. Also, multi-channel is rarely downmixed to stereo in case of HD content - for Blu-ray rips, however, only the core from Dolby TrueHD (640kbps AC3) or DTS-MA (1536kbps DTS) is generally used (at least in case of western content) instead of the full lossless audio (and in cases where lossless audio is used it is generally converted to FLAC because it compresses better). Just because rips have drastically smaller filesizes doesn't mean that they're going to have drastically lower quality, though - Blu-ray has limitations in the amount of H.264 features that can be used, and encoding applications also matter. x264, which is a FOSS H.264 encoder, is generally recognized as the best H.264 encoder in the world. If you use x264 and go above Blu-ray limits, hell even H.264 level 4.1 limits, or even encode in 10-bit, it's not uncommon that you'll be able to shave off over 50% of the file's original size or more (compared to the original .m2ts file on the BD) with no discernible loss in video or audio quality. In case of western content, people tend to mostly stick to level 4.1 8-bit H.264, though, because of hardware compatibility. 5.1 DTS/AC3 core is used instead of say, 5.1 AAC is used for compatibility reasons as well - because S/PDIF can't do 24-bit 5.1 LPCM. There is one scene that cares very little about hardware compatibility, though: the anime scene. You can find pretty much the most advanced video, audio and subtitle formats in use there, with 10-bit H.264 video going up to level 5.1, AAC/FLAC audio, very complex ASS subtitles, Matroska ordered chapters... it's quite fascinating, really.
- 4ad 14y agoFor a very expensive, not modest, line in Iran download is restricted to 128kbps while upload is probably less than that. But you completely missed the point the article is trying to make...