3 ms·
I appreciate the work done here. Been having this feeling that things have got worse recently but didn't think it could be model related. The most frustrating
by skippyboxedhero 6mo ago
I appreciate the work done here.
Been having this feeling that things have got worse recently but didn't think it could be model related.
The most frustrating aspect recently (I have learned and accepted that Claude produces bad code and probably always did, mea culpa) is the non-compliance. Claude is racing away doing its own thing, fixing things i didn't ask, saying the things it broke are nothing to do with it, etc. Quite unpleasant to work with.
The stuff about token consumption is also interesting. Minimax/Composer have this habit of extensive thinking and it is said to be their strength but it seems like that comes at a price of huge output token consumption. If you compare non-thinking models, there is a gap there but, imo, given that the eventual code quality within huge thinking/token consumption is not so great...it doesn't feel a huge gap.
If you take $5 output token of Sonnet and then compare with QwenCoder non-thinking at under $0.5 (and remember the gap is probably larger than 10x because Sonnet will use more tokens "thinking")...is the gap in code quality that large? Imo, not really.
Have been a subscriber since December 2024 but looking elsewhere now. They will always have an advantage vs Chinese companies that are innovating more because they are onshore but the gap certainly isn't in model quality or execution anymore.
- randomNumber7 6mo ago> fixing things i didn't ask, saying the things it broke are nothing to do with it, etc. Quite unpleasant to work with. maybe they tried to give it the characteristics of motivated junior developers
- skippyboxedhero 6mo agoclassic :D i did think when i wrote that maybe AGI is already here, definitely worked with enough devs like that
- ehnto 6mo agoI am still on an old version of CC on one machine, but the results are the same. More difficulty keeping it on track, convincing it timelines I suggest are correct etc. For example I had a deploy fail, and it would not believe that the new logs were not from a previous deploy. It was adamant it had fixed the issue, so the logs must be old logs.
- skippyboxedhero 6mo agoI was using web UI last night and it was unable to understand basic aspects of the task. Haven't seen it perform this badly since I began using two years ago. Was trying to track token usage/index with Cursor, and was unable to understand that running `find` wouldn't show what was in Cursor index. Multiple times.