2 ms·
I thought the net calculation was a little lame. There's an interesting literature on the relationships between IQ and economics on both individual and nationa
by gwern 14y ago
I thought the net calculation was a little lame.
There's an interesting literature on the relationships between IQ and economics on both individual and national levels (I've compiled some links in http://lesswrong.com/lw/7e1/rationality_quotes_september_2011/4r01 http://lesswrong.com/lw/7e1/rationality_quotes_september_201... ), but one of the key factors making it difficult is that while it's easy to observe correlations between IQ measured at some point and later income, it's not easy to figure out the additional wealth created!
Much of IQ's economic benefits seem to be related to zero-sum or positional games (only a few thousand students can be let into Harvard each year). However, an additional marginal case of autism is not zero-sum where one case of autism saves you $5m on, I dunno, Alzheimer's somewhere. It just makes everyone $5m worse off.
So, it's possible that most of that 'net benefit' is only the 'net benefit' as considered for the specific person, and a net loss on a society-wide scale (because while that person may be internalizing the benefit of hundreds of thousands of dollars, they're not externalizing any of the cost by paying for that extra autistic kid a few houses over, whose treatment is going to be subsidized to some degree by other people as well).
Calculating the society-wide gains and losses is much harder, and it seems he didn't even try.