3 ms·
> Why are we not refusing to implement this until we know we can make it work on all devices? Simply put: this will never happen. Way too many devices implemen
by ExoticPearTree 6mo ago
> Why are we not refusing to implement this until we know we can make it work on all devices?
Simply put: this will never happen. Way too many devices implementations to make this a reality.
- fsflover 6mo agoIt's just a matter of creating a web app.
- well_ackshually 6mo agoAnd what attestation services does your web app use? Do we lock that web app behind having Secure boot enabled, along with a Java applet for the fun of it? If your answer is "none", you missed the point.
- fsflover 6mo agoAttestation of what? It's none of your business how I secure and configure my phone. I use a smart card on my Librem 5 btw. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47647047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47647047
- well_ackshually 6mo agoMy business, no. Your government however, has a few reasons to want to ensure that the ID you're going to use to vote, to prove your identity to any service, etc, etc, does not get passed from device to device. Configure your phone however you want, then use your physical ID because your phone isn't supported. They're not taking it away. In the same way that you can file your taxes. Having an online filing service doesn't mean you're being "excluded" because your i386 running BeOS isn't part of the supported hardware. Send a letter. It'll still work.
- haagch 6mo agoI second the question, attestation of what? I have a Solo key that I use with webauthn for several services already. Is that not good enough and even if not, there surely are sufficient alternatives, least of all the actual electronic id on the national id card via nfc?