Scenario 2 makes sense. I think the counterpoint people bring up is to just stick to Scenario1 and let the salaries go up and let people jump ships every now an

Scenario 2 makes sense. I think the counterpoint people bring up is to just stick to Scenario1 and let the salaries go up and let people jump ships every now and then for a raise but they forget that C1 is a ultra-capitalist country.