3 ms·
Your [3] shows that the government enforces paying H1-Bs competitive salaries, not that it cares about the Americans they replaced.
by Noumenon72 7mo ago
Your [3] shows that the government enforces paying H1-Bs competitive salaries, not that it cares about the Americans they replaced.
- pj_mukh 7mo ago[flagged]
- nobodyandproud 7mo agoEasier to fire? Still costs less? Do what they’re told, because they’re chained to the company and job?
- mulmen 7mo agoBecause their H1B status is tied to their job so they will put up with way more abuse.
- thesmtsolver2 7mo agoIs there any data on this at all?
- mulmen 7mo agoH-1B is a non-immigrant work visa. This should be enough information for you to understand the incentives.
- thesmtsolver2 7mo agoSo, there is no data. Understood.
- mulmen 7mo agoWhat data is it you expect to see?
- bijowo1676 7mo agothey dont put up with abuse, it is very easy to change jobs on h-1b. the only reason to put up with abuse is boatloads of money, which is the primary reason why people change job (including the h-1bs)
- anonym29 7mo agoBecause H1b is an arrangement that more or less amounts to indentured servitude where vulnerable people have their visa status glued to their at-will employment agreement, resulting in a dynamic where employers can and frequently do expect unpaid overtime, fewer sick days, and otherwise disproportionately greater value from h1b employees, and those who fail to meet these unfair expectations are let go and effectively evicted from the country as it is extraordinarily rare to to secure another h1b job within 60 days. The number on two paystubs can be the exact same while one person is being brutally overworked and the other given a leisurely, comfortable WLB, which effectively amounts to underpaying the foreign labor, per unit of output, devaluing each unit of labor of domestic output.
- acchow 7mo agoH1b is tied to employment, not to the employer. You can change employers on the same H1. It’s not great. But this is similar to how health insurance is tied to employment, not to the employer. Both citizens and H1 employees experience the same abuse here
- sarchertech 7mo agoNo it’s worse for them. A person on an H-1B has a ticking time bomb to find a new job or leave the country.
- bijowo1676 7mo agoWhy would Oracle replace Americans with H-1Bs if they had to pay the same salaries?? Actually H-1Bs are more expensive than Americans due to visa costs and attorney costs, so Oracle can SAVE money by hiring Americans, yet they still decide to continue hiring H1Bs along with Americans.