3 ms·
If you get hit by a car, by law, the driver of that car should have liability insurance which will end up paying all your medical bills.
by philwelch 14y ago
If you get hit by a car, by law, the driver of that car should have liability insurance which will end up paying all your medical bills.
- azakai 14y agoShould, but not necessarily. People buy insurance for exactly that case, where the other motorist is uninsured or underinsured.
- frio 14y agoSo what if the shoe's on the other foot? A driver hits someone. The driver doesn't have insurance. He's now liable for the other person's medical bills, but can't afford them. He's now massively in debt over some random accident. No matter the moral judgment ("he shouldn't be driving without insurance"), the underlying point was that random debt does happen :).
- philwelch 14y agoNot only should he not be driving without insurance, but he's almost certainly at fault for hitting the pedestrian. We put some debtors into prison for lesser forms of irresponsibility.
- frio 14y agoThe point is: unexpected debt happens. Arguing semantics over a hypothetical case is not a meaningful tangent :).
- greedo 14y agoYou set up a strawman, and then change the point. Defending irresponsible behavior won't do much to improve things.
- elemenohpee 14y agoThat's great, unless he needs to drive to get to work in order to get a paycheck and keep his head above water for another week. Do people really not understand that there are people who do not have the luxury of a risk-free life?
- greedo 14y agoTeaching someone to measure risk is part of parenting, and a good sign of maturity. Driving without insurance is strike one in that calculus, and then hitting a pedestrian is strike two. Helping them out of debt is merely enabling strike three in this scenario. Take a look at your local newspapers mugshot section. Ours publishes them online, and when bored, it's a fun diversion. The majority of the arrests are for DUI, or driving on a suspended license from a prior DUI. A great cross section of people who don't even care about their impact upon others.
- elemenohpee 14y agoNot sure what DUIs have to do with this. I'm thinking about the guy who lost his job, and the closest position he could find was 50 miles away from his home, which he can't move out of without losing a lot of money. He's exhausted from the long commute each day and the stress of being up to his neck in debt, which is what he's distracted by when he doesn't see the pedestrian step out from behind a parked car. It's got nothing to do with maturity or whatever, it's about doing what is necessary to survive and provide for your family. It's pretty callous and insulting to tell someone in this situation that they deserve to be crushed under debt because you don't want to "enable" their behavior.
- greedo 14y agoAs a society, we expect people to follow norms of behavior; we usually call them laws. Driving without insurance is breaking the law. Driving impaired in the case of alcohol is against the law. Driving impaired because you're tired and exhausted and stressed about life and then striking a pedestrian is usually going to result in either criminal charges or civil charges at the minimum. You might even have to wear a sign... http://fxn.ws/SwNfY1 http://fxn.ws/SwNfY1 EDIT: Here's a link for people who think that anything coming from Fox should be dismissed out of hand immediately: http://security-today.com/Blogs/REACTION/2012/11/Woman-Sentenced-to-Wear-Idiot-Sign.aspx http://security-today.com/Blogs/REACTION/2012/11/Woman-Sente...
- Moto7451 14y agoUnless they don't (Or if you were in fact liable). Depending on the numbers you look at 1 in 7 drivers in uninsured or underinsured[1]. This is why you should have uninsured/underinsured coverage as part of your auto policy (on my policy it's $12 per year for $50,000 of coverage). [1] http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/nation/story/2011-09-11/uninsured-drivers/50363390/1 http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/nation/story/2011-09-11/...