3 ms·
At some point, if this becomes clearly inevitable, I'm hoping large-scale geoengineering happens. It would be awesome to be able to personally finance it, and
by rdl 14y ago
At some point, if this becomes clearly inevitable, I'm hoping large-scale geoengineering happens. It would be awesome to be able to personally finance it, and from what I've seen, it would be in the hundreds of millions of dollars, so a bunch of families could individually, or even a kickstarter circa 2025.
- rayiner 14y agoWhat do you mean by "geoengineering" in this specific context?
- maratd 14y agoWith about 100 mil worth of cash on an annual basis, you can pump enough sulfur into the stratosphere to cool the planet and keep the temps stable. It's pretty straightforward and a proven method (think volcano eruptions).
- rdl 14y agoJust spraying seawater into the air (from ships) would increase albedo (white clouds reflect much more incoming radiation than black seas), lowering temperature, in a pretty benign way. There's also iron seeding (to make algae). Bill Gates is funding it. I still think his work on Polio eradication is more valuable, but this is pretty awesome too.
- vlad_t 14y agoSpraying seawater also impacts in another way - produces a lot of aerosol (salt particles, and so on) which contributes a lot into pollution.
- rdl 14y agoAlso, the exciting thing about geoengineering is you don't really have to ask anyone's permission. If you had a random country flagged ship and a bunch of SO2, you could pretty much just do this thing without telling anyone. They would presumably see it from satellites after atmospheric sampling (and people with eyes in the evening) noticed, but I'm unclear what the legal process would be to stop it.
- AJ007 14y agoIn The Vanishing Face of Gaia James Lovelock theorizes that geoengineering would trigger a cascading effect of problems, much like a a sick patient on an ever increasing regimen of prescription medications, each solving one problem while causing three. While other portions of the book are questionable, I tend to agree with this analogy. The best case would be for the environment to re-balance itself -- of course, human cause or not, our environment is not static and is destined to continual change. Unfortunately James Lovelock's worst case scenario is an earth which is capable of producing enough food to support single digit percentages of the world's current population. That is a pretty brutal death sentence for the current state of human civilization.
- rdl 14y agoThere are changes humans make to the environment which do make it better (at least for humans) -- building dams on rivers which otherwise flood periodically, culling wood and undergrowth to keep large-scale forest fires from happening, etc. There are environmental costs to each of those, but the benefits (direct and economic) far outweigh them, and stuff like salmon ladders, helicopter transport, etc. can deal with some of the harm. The best long-term outcome for humanity is to use capitalism and science/technology to generate as much wealth as possible AND do as little damage to the environment as possible, but I think the "have a much lighter footprint and generate less wealth" option is off the table -- it's not going to be acceptable to generate less wealth than we have now, so really the most favorable outcome is to try to scale the wealth generation up faster than the harm done, and then use some wealth to ameliorate specific severe problems.
- oelewapperke 14y agoI don't think you can have it both ways. Either we can predict the effect of things on the environment (co2, and other things we could use for geoengineering), or we cannot. If you believe we cannot predict and prevent cascading problems or adapt to them then you're the same thing as a climate change denier, since who's to say that we got the cascading effect of co2 increase right ? If you believe we can predict those consequences, then geoengineering will allow the human race to take control of the climate. So the problem of climate change becomes the problem of finding the set of consequences we like best. Climate change becomes a problem similar to animals digging holes in a dam : an inconvenience to be monitored, but nothing more. This ignores political problems of course. Geoengineering would make one hell of a weapon of war, for example. China, given it's coastline, might choose to raise the sea level by 5 meters with little consequence for them, but major US population centers would become unliveable (New York, San Francisco), as would many European cities. Geoengineering, used like that, can do far more damage than 5000 nukes could.