3 ms·
Don't call semi-officially government sanctioned antisemitism with stupid euphemisms. It's plain insulting.
by shmerl 14y ago
Don't call semi-officially government sanctioned antisemitism with stupid euphemisms. It's plain insulting.
- ucee054 14y agoDon't conflate prejudice with anti-semitism. It's plain insulting.
- shmerl 14y agoBetter don't tell this "wisdom" to those who were discriminated in Russia. They won't appreciate it.
- ucee054 14y agoYou weren't talking about those who were discriminated against in Russia, you were talking about jews who were discriminated against in Russia. Implying that all the others who were discriminated against don't count. And there were lots of them. Including, by these articles, victimized by MGU admissions. EDIT: check out in the article where it says "These problems were designed to prevent Jewish people and other undesirables"
- shmerl 14y agoUniversities had national census not only for Jews obviously. This doesn't preclude the fact of that it was manifestation of antisemitism. If you don't get it - there is little point in explaining it to you.
- davidkatz 14y agoUnnecessary bashing. The OP singled Jews out, which framed this discussion mostly around Jews. Prejudice against Jews is called anti semitism. There's really nothing to see here, nobody implied that there was no discrimination against other groups.
- ucee054 14y agoWell in the first place framing this discussion mostly around jews is precisely the problem. Don't you understand why it is offensive? The same way it's offensive when my jewish relatives claim the Nazi genocide was the worst catastrophe in all history, conveniently forgetting the Cultural Revolution, the Cambodian Killing Fields, the Armenian Genocide etc etc So I don't like the use of the word "anti-semitism" in the first place. But what really annoys me is that it is a euphemism, and a hyped one at that. To a first approximation, anti-semite means Nazi. Prejudice against jews is correctly called judeophobia instead. shmerl managed both to commit this abuse of language and complain about the use of stupid euphemisms at the same time. And what he was complaining about - affirmative action to mean discrimination - is a far smaller abuse of language.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThe basic problem here is that Russia is blatantly, horrifically racist in general. I'm sharing an apartment with a Russian Jew who shows no outward signs of Jewish practice or culture, but whose father nonetheless had to live a double-life between Russia and America just because he was descended from Jewish stock. That's plainly racial antisemitism and every bit deserving of the word.
- ucee054 14y agoAgreed. <pedantic> Are you clear that "anti-semitism" carries some meaning other than "prejudice against jews"? So if you use it to mean "prejudice against jews" it is a euphemism. I can give you the history of the term if you like. </pedantic>
- davidkatz 14y agoIt's hard to look into your head and understand what exactly anti-semitism means to you. For anti-semitism to qualify as a euphemism, we'd have to establish that: 1. It actually has some substantial meaning outside of 'prejudice/discrimination against jews' 2. It is offensive beyond the offence that one might take from being accused of prejudice/discrimination against jews As for (1), here's some dictionary definitions: Merriam-Webste: hostility toward or discrimination against Jews as a religious, ethnic, or racial group Collins: prejudice or hostility towards Jews Cambridge: the strong dislike or cruel and unfair treatment of Jewish people I'm not clear on what sort of historial narrative you could provide that would 'load' this term with substantial additional meaning and offense, but it would have to be very convincing.
- ucee054 14y agoUniversities had national census not only for Jews obviously. Then complain in your comment about all the people treated unfairly, don't mention anti-semitism only. If you don't get this - there is little point in explaining it to you.