4 ms·
Shouldn't such an extralegal system make them into a publisher exercising editorial control over the content? Wouldn't this then disqualify them for safe harbo
by chongli 14y ago
Shouldn't such an extralegal system make them into a publisher exercising editorial control over the content?
Wouldn't this then disqualify them for safe harbor?
- theevocater 14y agoI think the usual analogy is one of a private space. Youtube is Google's private pool that is nominally open to the public. If you break their rules, you get thrown out.
- dpe82 14y agoDMCA Safe Harbor protections apply to copyrighted material stored "at the direction of a user". YouTube is not making judgements about the content - if they did, it would no longer be "at the direction of a user." Instead they've set up a system that lets other users (copyright holders) control content on the site. YouTube does not try to figure out whether those users' actions are valid - if they did, /then/ they could lose safe harbor. DMCA does not explicitly require ContentID type systems, but it's becoming recognized as best practice as it makes it easier to show a court "hey, we're trying to be good corporate citizens here." It also pacifies the content companies which helps prevent lawsuits in the first place. Source: currently doing research on the topic for our own service.