I left that bit of information out of the post but I actually had a copy of the Keychains directory before I mv-ed login-1.keychain-db to login.keychain-db. Sin

I left that bit of information out of the post but I actually had a copy of the Keychains directory before I mv-ed login-1.keychain-db to login.keychain-db. Since that confirmed my hunch it probably gave the sense I was confident in moving instead of renaming.