3 ms·
I wish we lived in more of a "spirit of the law" world than a "letter of the law" world, where everything needs to be spelled out, but we don't. A small minorit
by ryandrake 7mo ago
I wish we lived in more of a "spirit of the law" world than a "letter of the law" world, where everything needs to be spelled out, but we don't. A small minority of people enjoy Rules Lawyering their way through life, insisting on trying to "gotcha" counterparties who are acting in good faith, so as a consequence, we all have to be Rules Lawyers and everything needs to be spelled out.
- d3ckard 7mo agoNo, you don’t. It only sounds nice. In practice this enables all kinds of spontaneous prosecution with any possible motive.
- WesolyKubeczek 7mo agoTheoretically, courts and judges exist precisely to balance the word and the spirit, and find and judge the actual intent. In practice, I'm in awe that good judgments still happen, despite everything.
- xboxnolifes 7mo agoWe live in neither. Many things spelled out are unenforceable. Maybe things not spelled out are implied. We live in a world where advertising boneless chicken does not actually mean the chicken does not contain bones.
- NetMageSCW 7mo agoI think a “spirit of the law” world would result in judges that already abuse their absurd powers way too much have free rein over any abuse they want to do, and there would be no system for ensuring everyone is treated equally or fairly.
- vkou 7mo agoThe current alternative is the corpos abuse their absurd powers, and there's no system for ensuring everyone is treated equally or fairly.