5 ms·
Video About Fair Use, Remix and Culture Taken Down Over Copyright Claim
- icebraining 14y agoI wonder why do people making these kinds of videos keep uploading them to Youtube. Are they trying to get blocked to make a point? Because otherwise, it seems just stupid. EDIT: 001sky is right, I didn't realize this was an old video.
- SeanDav 14y ago> I wonder why do people making these kinds of videos keep uploading them to Youtube. Are they trying to get blocked to make a point? Because otherwise, it seems just stupid. Wow, you have been on HN for over 500 days and have over 6k karma and can make a comment like that. Since they don't usually hand out karma in lucky packets I can only assume you are having a bad day.
- acuozzo 14y agoKarma is currency to those wanting to write a controversial comment.
- citricsquid 14y agoWhat's a "lucky packet"? I've never heard that term before.
- nekojima 14y agoIt has several names, including hong bao or red envelope. More often associated with Chinese/Lunar New Year celebrations. https://www.google.com/search?q=hong+bao&hl=en&tbo=u&tbm=isch&source=univ&sa=X&ei=ExOcUIX2C4u02AXKqoGYAg&ved=0CEoQsAQ&biw=1366&bih=643 https://www.google.com/search?q=hong+bao&hl=en&tbo=u...
- monochromatic 14y agoLet's not turn this into reddit, please.
- nitrogen 14y agoMashup videos (and especially videos documenting them) are a form of art and commentary that is worthy of protection.
- icebraining 14y agoI agree completely, and I completely disagree with Youtube's policy, but that's just one more reason not to promote the site by uploading videos to it. Boycott them! (Of course, as I wrote later, I hadn't realized the video was old, which makes my comment rather idiotic)
- nitrogen 14y agoAh, I see. I got the impression from your comment and edit that you were taking a hard-line copyright maximalism stance.
- nitrogen 14y agoMashup videos (and especially videos documenting them) are a form of art and commentary that is worthy of protection.
- btilly 14y agoI don't understand how there can be no appeal process. My understanding (see http://www.chillingeffects.org/dmca512/faq.cgi http://www.chillingeffects.org/dmca512/faq.cgi for instance) of the DMCA is pretty straightforward. If you wish to have safe harbor, you must respond to notices and counter-notices. So if you send a counter-notice and are not sued in 2 weeks, the material has to be put back up. If Youtube fails to do so, they lose their safe harbor and have an insane amount of potential liability. What am I missing?
- theevocater 14y agoI think the reason is that their system is not DMCA. They respect the DMCA but also provide a stronger (for the rightsholders) service that was triggered here. ContentID makes them judge, jury and executioner.
- btilly 14y agoThat would be a good reason. If so then I am sure that they thought through the liability issues (if any). I'm curious if there are any interesting ones. The only thing that comes to mind would be a case where the ownership of a piece of IP is disputed. ContentID lead to Youtube recognizing that it was copyrighted, and paying money to the person that they thought was the copyright holder. The copyright holder now sues Youtube for infringing on copyright, and Youtube has deep pockets and no safe harbor. I am not sure how realistic this case would be.
- theevocater 14y agoThis happens all the time. They go through the proper DMCA process (which google obeys) and then correctly register with ContentID (theory). In reality, the big publishers stomp all over little guys and they have no standing to do anything.
- chongli 14y agoShouldn't such an extralegal system make them into a publisher exercising editorial control over the content? Wouldn't this then disqualify them for safe harbor?
- mproud 14y agoThe video is not blocked anymore. See: http://youtu.be/4BZ06Kwbi5s http://youtu.be/4BZ06Kwbi5s