3 ms·
What I don't get is why the heck are the astronauts willing to risk their lives on something they must know by now is so dangerous? Is it really better to risk
by dataflow 8mo ago
What I don't get is why the heck are the astronauts willing to risk their lives on something they must know by now is so dangerous? Is it really better to risk death than to risk getting fired?
- shawn_w 8mo agoThere aren't many people left who've been that close to the moon. Lots of people would love to be on that list.
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- FpUser 8mo agoSome people go to war for the thrill of it, others do base jumping, free solo climbing and whole lot of other activities that eventually kill many of them. It is in their genes.
- renewiltord 8mo agoThis degree of lifespan-maximization is something you might have but others don’t necessarily share. E.g. old people went to Fukushima to sort it out. “Was it really better to risk death than to risk getting fired?” Neither of these are major risks compared to never being what you want to be.
- wiseowise 8mo ago> Neither of these are major risks compared to never being what you want to be. I want you to repeat those words as you melt away re-entering the atmosphere.
- renewiltord 8mo agoThat’s not my purpose so dying that way doesn’t seem that appealing.
- wiseowise 8mo agoReplace it with whatever you consider “worth dying for”.
- renewiltord 8mo agoIn that case it seems all right. Certainly if I died in Apollo 1 and I cared about spaceflight and making it to the Moon before the Russians I wouldn’t see it as unworthy. The Shuttle deaths no problem.
- spike021 8mo agoTo be honest I don't know how close to non-fiction "The Right Stuff" (book or film) was but if you watch it you'd maybe gain an understanding for why astronauts do these things. At least that part is believable.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8mo ago> why are the astronauts willing to risk their lives There are a lot of funerals in chapter 1 of Tom Wolfe's book, "The Right Stuff". I suggest that some choice of profession come with a higher life-risk tolerance than others. "Accountants willing to risk their lives for the job" would be news. Firefighters, less so. Test pilots or astronauts, not much at all.
- dataflow 8mo agoYou're completely ignoring the nature of the risk. It's one thing to accept a risk of death because it's intrinsic to a noble job. It's a whole other thing to accept a totally avoidable risk that's only introduced due to management's self-interests getting in the way.
- SideburnsOfDoom 8mo agoI agree, to the extent that those two categories are easily and clearly separable and not murky due to the nature of risk, and efforts to pass off one as the other.
- voxic11 8mo agoBecause even in the worst case what we are really talking about is just much higher risk than the government is claiming, but its still far more likely to succeed than fail. Plenty of people would take a 1 in 10 or 1 in 100 chance of dying if it meant they could walk on the moon.