4 ms·
Professors Regard Online Instruction as Less Effective Than Classroom Learning
- thredup 18y agoImagine that? Who loses when online instruction wins? Professors. This has been a problem for innovation in education for decades. Established interests have a seat at the table, but not kids. Did anybody ask students about their experience? The beauty of online learning is that it is a supplement to core instruction that can be paced to meet the needs of students. As a replacement to AP english it probably is not as effective but when schools cut out German, what's a kid to do? Clay Christensen notes this in his new book, Disrupting Class - I'd encourage anyone thinking about innovation in education (especially as it relates to online learning) to read this important book.
- gcheong 18y agoI'm not sure why it would have to take longer to prepare for an online class vs. a regular class. I had been taking online graduate CS courses through DePaul University and those were set up as regular classes with an online component being recorded. All the technology was there to view slide presentations, capture writing on a physical whiteboard, and recording of the lecture which made not only distance learning possible but reviewing the material possible for the regular students. All assignments were submitted online as well. The only time it seemed extra onerous to the professor was one time when the professor forgot to set the equipment to record and he had to redo the lecture for the distance learning students.
- niels_olson 18y agoLess effective at what? Job protection? My own survey suggests it is almost equally as effective http://nielsolson.us/STLHE020409/Olson_TimeValueOfStudyHabits_STLHE.pdf http://nielsolson.us/STLHE020409/Olson_TimeValueOfStudyHabit... more context here: http://nielsolson.us/Haversian/2009/02/some_current_thoughts_on_teach.php http://nielsolson.us/Haversian/2009/02/some_current_thoughts...
- miked 18y agoThere's not a shred of real data about learning outcomes in that article, only subjective opinions from decidedly biased sources. Also, there's no hint of a cost-benefit analysis. Online instruction may not be as good, but it should be much cheaper and save time, which could still make it worth it. Universities are bloated bureaucracies full of people who can't be fired (for the most part), most of whom don't really want to teach.