4 ms·
I think you should make proper counter arguments instead of dismissing something because they used a specific tool. Ad-HomineLLM is a logical fallacy IMO and a
by ddtaylor 7mo ago
I think you should make proper counter arguments instead of dismissing something because they used a specific tool.
Ad-HomineLLM is a logical fallacy IMO and adds little value. I would hope eventually HN and other sites add this to the guidelines similar to other claims like vote manipulation etc.
- treykeown 7mo agoSorry, making up a word to try and frame distrust of LLM-generated content as a “logical fallacy” is a bad take. HN doesn’t have guidelines against anti-LLM rhetoric, but it does for LLM-generated comments. > Don't post generated comments or AI-edited comments. HN is for conversation between humans. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#generated https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html#generated
- nazgul17 7mo agoGP was arguing against the OP, not a comment, and AI written posts are fair game. Also, the comment you responded to was criticizing the attack to the substance of the post based on who/what wrote is. The comment neologism actually fits, IMO.