3 ms·
The thing that strikes me the most is how dated this is already. Tagging -- the novel concept it introduces at great length -- won, and all the motivating argum
by gruseom 18y ago
The thing that strikes me the most is how dated this is already. Tagging -- the novel concept it introduces at great length -- won, and all the motivating arguments for it just seem obvious now.
Obviously, that's not a criticism of the piece itself, which is very good. It's just so (... quickly look up date ...) 2005.
- silentbicycle 18y agoI agree, but I think it has interesting parallels to problems that crop up in sufficiently complicated OO class hierarchy designs, and I'm not sure that discussion surrounding "design patterns" has fully acknowledged such issues. People in some other niches (librarians, for one) have spent a lot of time thinking about these problems. They're generally struggling with managing a different kind of complexity than programmers are, but I'd love to see more cross-pollination of ideas. I'm just trying to generate discussion.
- gruseom 18y agoThat's true, a lot of the fundamental problems are the same. I suppose OO design patterns are workarounds for some of them. Some time ago I read a collection of articles by Michael Jackson (the computing one) and it turns out he was making similar arguments against this kind of ontology in the 70s. Incidentally, I always thought "ontology" meant "philosophy of being", not cataloguing systems.
- dasil003 18y agoTo be fair, it wasn't novel at the time either (why is there no date on the article?). What I find interesting is that it does point out some of the unfulfilled promise of tag data-mining. We have all these tags now, but we're still very far from extracting their full value.
- bitdiddle 18y agoyea, I posted it ages ago for several karma points on Reddit :) Still a good read though