3 ms·
This is empty madness. It is, very literally, a celebration of total materialism. What is madness to you may not be madness to dcutis, and messy human beings a
by kiba 14y ago
This is empty madness. It is, very literally, a celebration of total materialism.
What is madness to you may not be madness to dcutis, and messy human beings are not all there is worthwhile in the universe. Would you want to watch a reality tv show that records the uglyness and pettyness of human nature?
I honestly rather discuss and learn about things rather than about drama-queen contestant #3.
- Swizec 14y agoI hear a lot of people have gotten very rich by making reality shows that record the uglyness and pettyness of human nature.
- anigbrowl 14y agoDustin Curtis's problem here is that he thinks his subjective preferences are objectively true. I mean, if he says 'I love this flatware because it has these beautiful proportions, is manufactured in such-and-such a way, and exudes timeless quality etc. etc.', then great - he's a good designer, I'm interested in his aesthetic philosophy. But when he says 'I am the arbiter of quality' he's lost me. By doing so, he rejects the possibility of tastes other than his own and comes off as absurdly egotistical. I don't know if Dustin Curtis is married, but if not he may be in for a bit of a surprise down the road, when it turns out that his view is not the only one that matters.
- tlrobinson 14y agoHis response to another comment here is directly counter to your assumptions about him: The problem is that "the best" is different for everyone. I can post some of the things that are the best to me, but it's also about the journey of finding out what really matters to you. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4755552 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4755552
- anigbrowl 14y agoWell no. Sure, he assumes each individual will find their own best things. But I suspect that if you too have strong opinions about flatware, it can only end in a knife fight.
- hartleybrody 14y agoDid you read the full article? He's not claiming to be an 'arbiter of quality' at all, he's using the flatware as an example. He specifically says that it's up to each person to determine the best things for themselves: > It requires that you find the best thing for yourself, which means you need to know what actually matters to you.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI did, and that qualifier struck me as little more than a figleaf.
- reinhardt 14y ago> Dustin Curtis's problem here is that he thinks his subjective preferences are objectively true. And that's exactly what mapgrep did too with "what is ultimately important in life are people". Seriously? Glad for you if you've found that people and building connections is your calling in life but if you try to shove your subjective preference down others' throats you aren't any better in principle than Curtis. FWIW I don't particularly care for either materialism, people or connections (that's nihilistic tendencies for you) but I'm not trying to convince anyone.
- unconed 14y agoI don't think he actually believes that, but I think his writing style absolutely exudes it. And the fact that he has his own minimalist-styled exclusive blogger network only emphasizes it. I love the fact that all Svbtle blogs look alike though. Makes it easy to spot and instantly close the tab as being just more privileged valley wankery.
- javert 14y agoI'm generally on your side in this argument, but I want to point out that not all human beings are ugly and petty, although many may be. When it comes to finding human beings to spend time with, you have to use the same intense sense of value, judgement, and love of a good product, that dcurtis applies to flatware selection. We are our own greatest products.
- kiba 14y agoHuman beings can be very interesting, but if exposed incorrectly, they're also dull.