6 ms·
“Don’t buy this computer.”
- Cbasedlifeform 14y agoI was all set to upgrade my 2011 MBA to the rMBP 13" but on reflection I'll stick with the MBA for now... I do most serious coding on an external monitor anyway. I gather the 2012 MBA is significantly faster than my 2011 version.
- aoe 14y agoOfftopic: Which external monitor do you use? I'm thinking of getting the 27" Apple one, but waiting to see if they would release a retina-resolution anytime soon.
- dabeeeenster 14y agoNot going to happen any time soon - the GPU power needed (esp from a laptop) is a few years off I think. Dont get the Apple display - just get a Korean knock off with the same panel for a quarter of the price...
- kylec 14y agoThe Thunderbolt display is expensive, but it also has a lot more than just the panel - it has a webcam, speakers, USB, firewire, ethernet, and a MagSafe connector to charge a MacBook, not to mention that gorgeous aluminum and glass body. Worth $999? Maybe not, but it's definitely not equivalent to a Korean display off eBay.
- aoe 14y agoQuarter? really? could you link me?
- aoe 14y agoJust found this - http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2012/07/the-ips-lcd-revolution.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2012/07/the-ips-lcd-revolut...
- goldenchrome 14y agoAtwood did a decent write up about them. It's a good place to start. http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2012/07/the-ips-lcd-revolution.html http://www.codinghorror.com/blog/2012/07/the-ips-lcd-revolut... Edit: and you found it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jsolson 14y agoThey could always build a Thunderbolt display with a built-in GPU.
- calinet6 14y agoAbsolutely—it's effectively a PCIe x2 external interface. There's plenty of bandwidth.
- adestefan 14y agoDon't forget to factor in $70 - $100 (and the loss of the a USB port) for the miniDP to dual-link DVI adapter you need to drive one of those panels.
- yusefnapora 14y agoYou'll probably need a Mini DisplayPort to Dual-link DVI adapter as well, if you're driving one of the Korean displays from a recent Mac. Apple sells one for a hundred dollars, or monoprice has one for $70: http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=104&cp_id=10428&cs_id=1042802&p_id=6904&seq=1&format=2 http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=104&c... Just something to keep in mind when you're budgeting.
- tubelite 14y agoIn a store full of big-screen TVs, laptops, tablets and every species of shining rectangle, one device emits a reality-distortion field like no other: the iMac. The display is just.. perfect. After seeing the iMac 2 years ago, I switched to e-IPS (Dell 2209WA, then the Dell U2312HM), but somehow they're not in the same league. Way better than TN LCDs, of course, but not iMac/Cinema display. Is e-IPS that much worse than IPS? Perhaps it's Apple's calibration which does the trick? I don't know. I would love to find a cheap monitor which used the same panel as the iMac and had similar image quality. Any pointers?
- Cbasedlifeform 14y agoI spoiled myself with the Apple thunderbolt display I confess, and love it. But I did not research all the alternatives and no doubt I paid the Apple premium tax. No doubt there are better deals but if say the premium is $350 over a 3 year lifetime (at least) it's a few starbucks coffees or meals out per year for something I use hours per day :)
- kylec 14y agoIf you're not going to use the screen then it's probably not worth the premium over the MacBook Air for you. However, the rMBP does have other advantages over the Air, namely faster processors and two Thunderbolt ports instead of the Air's one.
- kylec 14y agoHere's the discussion from yesterday about the article Marco linked to: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4750276 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4750276
- nickporter 14y agoThe true resolution of the 13" rMBP is 2560×1600, 15" rMBP is 2880×1800. That means even if you are getting a scaled down resolution of 1440×900, the real resolution of the display is still obscenely high. Everything is MUCH sharper than on the regular displays. The fonts are gorgeous. I own a 15" rMBP. I can change the scaled resolution to 1680×1050 or 1920×1200, without loss of details. Seriously, there is no fuzziness or anything sort of BS like that. I think Marco needs glasses. One problem with this laptop is with non-retina ready apps and some websites. Since the display is at such a high resolution, smaller images will appear a bit blurry (because of the upscaling algorithms), but its really not that bad. Non-retina ready apps will look pixelated, and it sucks. But most popular apps are retina-ready, so again, it's not a big problem. Another problem is because you are rendering stuff at such a high resolution, there may be performance issues in some apps. Most of them were optimized for this (e.g. sublime text 2).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- hboon 14y agoA related tip: for non-retina ready apps, going to properties (Cmd+i) in Finder and checking Open in Low Resolution can help a lot.
- calinet6 14y agoAnd the technology is fairly young, and things will continue to improve. You speak the truth. The original article is hogwash and should be ignored with prejudice.
- otakucode 14y agoI am a bit confused. If the resolution is 2560x1600, why don't you run it at 2560x1600? The idea of not running a panel at its native resolution bothers me greatly. Is it the case that you're not able to run the system at its actual native resolution? That seems to be what these articles are saying, but they all seem to be dancing around it or assuming I've read something I haven't.
- adestefan 14y agoI'm more worried about the HD 4000 driving a Retina display than I am about the resolution. I moved from a 15" MBP to a 13" MBP and it's never really bothered me.
- niels_olson 14y agoI leave my 15" rMBP in 1920 mode. Having two full A4 or 8.5x11 sheets of paper next to each other is too valuable when studying or doing research. The texts are invariably in PDF format. If I'm working on my notes, I'm on the web, if I'm working on a paper, I'm in LibreOffice. If I'm working on code, it's in emacs. Generally, inputs are on the right, and the working text is on the left. I frankly have no other use for such an incredible machine. I just wanted the screen.
- kbutler 14y agoHow does the retina screen scaled 1920x1080 compare to a laptop with native 1920x1080? I'd expect the native 1920x1080 to actually yield a sharper image than retina scaled down. I realize Apple doesn't provide a native 1920x1080, but it's not hard to find in non-Apple 15" laptops, at an easy $1,000 cost savings for higher-performance components (but less thin-and-light).
- driverdan 14y ago> How does the retina screen scaled 1920x1080 compare to a laptop with native 1920x1080? IMO it looks much better. Only rasterized objects are scaled. Fonts and native components still render at full DPI. > I realize Apple doesn't provide a native 1920x1080, but it's not hard to find in non-Apple 15" laptops, at an easy $1,000 cost savings for higher-performance components (but less thin-and-light). Good luck finding one with equal or better build quality that will run a POSIX OS flawlessly (no driver issues, no hacking configs or recompiling, etc) and costs $1000 less. I looked at a lot of other hardware before buying my 15" rMBP and couldn't find anything that measured up.
- niels_olson 14y agoI have owned a Dell Latitude D820 with a WUXGA (1920 X 1200) screen since 2006(-ish?). It is good, but not nearly as good at the Retina, and the screen is more square, making two sheets side-by-side feel awkward.
- brudgers 14y agoThat scaling pixelated displays produces less satisfactory results than native resolutions is not news. What is noteworthy is that the direction Apple is headed is toward competing on specifications such as pixel count rather than functional design. Retina branding is in no small part about competing on pixel count. It is not significantly about competing on productivity. Personally, if I am admiring the rendering of fonts on my screen, either the content is less than compelling or I am graphically designing with inadequate attention to a real world audience.
- tammer 14y agoGood analysis. 'Pro', to me, means more screen real-estate, not less. Consumer, as in the consumption of content, means a sharper, prettier screen with a lower effective resolution. It's interesting that in this iteration, it seems that these qualities have switched product lines. The Air now seems to be the choice for professional work, for the reasons you describe in your last sentence. I do hope that as they roll out the display across their products they continue to ship a model with a larger effective@native resolution.
- jfb 14y agoI am a "pro". I care far more about the quality of the display than the putative resolution.
- calinet6 14y agoYour argument is silly and pretentious. The quality of the Retina screen is simply better—no fanboyism, no dogma, it's just a higher quality picture, period. It's nice to read sharper fonts, it's nice that the interface scales natively, and it just looks great. It's not about "admiring" anything, it's not about being out-of-touch with the "real world audience"—it's just a higher quality piece of technology. Furthermore, this statement from the original article is simply false: "the 13” Retina, like the 15” Retina, can scale to a simulated 1680 × 1050, but it doesn’t look nearly as good" As the author notes, the only problem with the higher-resolution scaling is performance, and even then the Intel 4000 integrated graphics actually still handles it with relative ease. Apple is slightly ahead of their time here. The technology really is stunning, and in practical use it still works well. Performance is a slight issue when scaling to higher desktop areas, but the tradeoff for more real estate is more than worth it. The truth is that the screen gives you more options for how to size and use your display, not fewer as this article seems to imply. The limitations are slight, and in this and future models, software and hardware will surely continue to improve. In short: the death of the high-dpi display has been greatly exaggerated. Don't pay attention to this FUD, just try one yourself for an extended period of time.
- pzaich 14y agoI've had my "retina" 15" since August and have been running it at 1920x1200 pretty much from Day 1. Coming from Macbook Pro's at 1440x900 and 1680x1050, it is definitely an adjustment. But honestly, I would never go back now. I can actually prefer coding on a single screen now! If something is too small, I can usually get away just bumping up the scaling in browser. I haven't experienced/noticed any kind of fuzziness or performance issues with scrolling. By far the best computer I've owned.
- mwill 14y agoAnyone with the 15" rMBP, if you haven't tried it yet, grab an app called SetResX (There are others, but SetResX is free and the only one I've actually tried). It'll let you force the screen to 2880x1800. This might just be me, but I love to code like this, splitting different windows to different corners of the screen. I used to use a 30" 2560x1600, and the rMBP @ 2880x1800 lets me keep the same workflow I love on a laptop. Admittedly it takes a little getting used to and such a high res on a small screen isn't for everyone, but if you've got one, give it a try at least once.
- calinet6 14y agoI simultaneously envy your eyesight and pity what you are doing to it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- SquareWheel 14y agoTry replacing your asterisks with x's, or escape them. It's triggering Markdown.
- mwill 14y agoWhoops, done, thanks.
- sneak 14y agoCould you please put contact info in your HN profile? I'd like to email or IM you.
- SquareWheel 14y agoSure, I've linked to my site where you can find email/other methods for contact.
- nsxwolf 14y agoI second this. This has to be seen to be believed (if your eyes can manage it). More real estate than the old 30" cinema display, in a 15" diagonal screen. It's a miracle.
- BryanB55 14y agoI've had the old 15" macboo pro, a 13" air and now the 15" retina. Never noticed less space on the screen. Only thing I did notice was everything is more crisp. Doesn't bother me at all.
- DeepDuh 14y agoI think part of the reason is that you can now read much smaller text, so you don't have to fiddle around the zoom level all the time. The chrome and top menu could be a bit smaller but it's not really a bit issue for me when browsing. For coding one can still switch to higher resolutions and it's a joy too.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- nsxwolf 14y agoI'd love to someday see the return of the 17" MBP, in Retina form. There would be no compromise in screen real estate in the hiDPI mode, and the full-native hack would provide mind-boggling space. The 17" sold poorly, but was it because of the size or the weight? If it was the weight, maybe there's a chance.
- wonderyak 14y agoI should think it was the price first, then the size and the weight. That was an extremely expensive laptop. If they brought it back, I'd be afraid to ask what kind of GPU it takes to drive a 17" Retina screen on a laptop.
- magikarp 14y agoWhat is this nonsense? You can easily set the display resolution to 1440x900 (or higher) in your 13" Retina Macbook's display settings.
- mcguire 14y agoI don't really follow Apple products. What is this "effective" screen size bit?
- MaysonL 14y agoAnd here's a screenshot of what 1920x1200 looks like on a non-Retina 15" MBP (Running 10.8.2 under Parallels): http://i.imgur.com/RKaiZ.jpg?1 http://i.imgur.com/RKaiZ.jpg?1