3 ms·
It doesn't work like that. Polls are not independent. If poll A is out by a large amount, then it's much more likely that poll B is also out. As well, the
by bryanlarsen 14y ago
It doesn't work like that. Polls are not independent. If poll A is out by a large amount, then it's much more likely that poll B is also out. As well, the confidence interval assumes that the sample was a fair sample, which is highly unlikely. It's very very difficult to get a true random sample of the voting populace. It's hard enough to get a random sample of the populace, and a random sample of those who vote is even harder.
That's why Nate Silver said that Romney had about a 10% chance of winning. Statistically it was much lower, but there was a very real chance of systematic polling errors.
- crntaylor 14y agoPolls are not independent. If poll A is out by a large amount, then it's much more likely that poll B is also out. That's a bias issue - I was only addressing sampling variation. If you wnat your model to address bias as well, of course you can build that in, given some priors on what the distribution of the bias is likely to be. I didn't bother in my model (which is why I was forecasting 98-99% chance of an Obama victory). We could discuss potential poll bias as well, but I thought that was a bit too much for this short comment.