2 ms·
If all you had is a reference document on the instruction set, are you saying the hard part is already done? Or that the hard part would be figuring out how to
by astrodust 14y ago
If all you had is a reference document on the instruction set, are you saying the hard part is already done? Or that the hard part would be figuring out how to implement that?
- rayiner 14y agoBut MIPS doesn't sell the instruction set reference. They sell CPU cores. So you have a blueprint that shows you exactly how the CPU works. The hard part is coming up with this blueprint, including things like designing caches to minimize power or structuring execution units to improve timing characteristics. That takes lots of expensive engineer time, iteration, testing, etc. But once all that information is distilled into a blueprint, it's relatively easy to actually implement it. Copyright protects you from literal copying of the blueprint. It doesn't protect you from someone just looking at your blueprint and implementing it. I used to work on military radios, and we spent millions of dollars and years developing our technology. The bulk of that investment was coming up with designs that worked well. We shipped customers reference code. Copyright kept the customer from copying the code itself, but didn't stop them from looking at how our code worked and writing their own version. But the code was the easy part--once you knew exactly what the code should do, it was a matter of 3-6 months of fairly straightforward coding to reproduce it without literally copying the code. It wasn't like say Windows where the hard part is literally reproducing all those 10 million lines of code.
- air 14y ago"It doesn't protect you from someone just looking at your blueprint and implementing it." I don't think this is true. You are creating a derived work, after all. Googling for blueprint and copyright shows that copyright disallows unauthorized implementation at least in the case of buildings.
- cwzwarich 14y agoMIPS also sells instruction set licenses if you want to build your own MIPS core from scratch.
- astrodust 14y agoThat's a somewhat valid point, but protecting that sort of innovation with patents is still extremely heavy handed. Just as software can be licensed with terms, surely these "blueprints" can be licensed with very specific regulations on how and where they can be used. Violating that agreement, which is very specific in nature, would be a lot more reasonable to enforce than what we have now. Those patents that've been sold off are most likely going to be used to shake-down other companies and lock out innovation. The most exploitable will be cherry picked, shunted into shell companies, and in time some jury in East Texas will have to make a decision on how many billions in damages need to be awarded.
- rayiner 14y agoI think the key aspect you're missing, though, is that contracts cannot enforced against people who are not party to the contract. If some company sits down and reverse engineers your design, you have no recourse. If your design gets leaked, you have no recourse. You have no way to protect something which is complex and expensive to derive but simple to copy. I mean neither of us have the data to show just how heavy handed or not the patent system actually is. I don't think it's particularly heavy handed, but then again my experience is in industries (defense, telecom) where "heavy" means something quite different. At least outside the software realm, my intuition is that companies illegitimately ripping off another company's designs is a bigger problem than companies accidentally arriving at similar designs and patents being used to "shake them down." I also think it's disingenuous to paint a picture where you have "100% innovation" on one side of the spectrum, with any patent rights as "locking out innovation." Again, because of my background I tend to see the innovation process as not a couple of guys in a garage doing some Kickstarter-funded web page, but companies working with universities and the government to build big technologies that require huge amounts of capital investment. The patent regime really facilitates those interactions, and I think increases innovation in doing so. When you're dealing with big organizations, a predictable set of property rights is much preferable to a fragile web of NDA's.