5 ms·
> (1) We have > 300 M people. That's a huge population. It's hilarious when Americans use that as an excuse for things being sub-par in their country. I see it
by grecy 14y ago
> (1) We have > 300 M people. That's a huge population.
It's hilarious when Americans use that as an excuse for things being sub-par in their country. I see it all the time for health care, roads, schools etc.
Yes, your country has lots of people in it, but it also takes in an enormous amount of tax, and has enormous government agencies to organize this kind of thing. Everything should scale up appropriately, but you guys have no figured that out yet.
- danielrhodes 14y agoYou are right. Countries scale up linearly just like websites do. How stupid of us to think otherwise.
- grecy 14y agoI did not use the word linear. Obviously scaling is hard, but I would expect that's one of the things a well functioning, well funded government should take care of, much like how Facebook and Google manage to scale well.
- wpietri 14y agoYour mistake is in thinking that Americans want a well-functioning, well-funded government. Some do, but a substantial swathe of America is currently, for one reason or another, opposed to that.
- grecy 14y agoRight. So it has nothing to do with the size of the population, and everything to do with people not wanting to pay tax. So to summarize, it's hilarious when Americans use the large population excuse for having sub-par services.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mrb 14y agoIf Canada and the US merged, would it be twice as hard to vote? Of course not. Voting is the most trivial govt activity to scale up! It is the equivalent of an embarrassingly parallel pb. The "300M citizens" excuse is even less valid in the context of presidential elections, because each state plans it independently from the others. So it is more like 52 tiny countries voting together!
- danielrhodes 14y agoIt is parallel, but not all jobs are run on the same hardware/software and you can't re-run jobs which error out. In fact, some jobs don't error out but should be invalid and if discovered as such might cast doubt on the authenticity of other jobs, etc. etc. So it's really not as trivial as you make it out to be, and neither is anything else which involves coordinating 100M+ people doing a particular task.
- gavinlynch 14y ago@daneilrhodes: you took the words right out of my mouth. I had no idea scaling was so simple. OP: When has this been used as an excuse for anything that you are apparently deeming as 'sub-standard' here in America? Cite a source please? Gotta be honest, I've never heard that excuse once. I also had no idea the rest of the world had solved the problem of civics and effective government. Why are you guys keeping it a secret? Care to share?
- pnathan 14y ago> It's hilarious when Americans use that as an excuse for things being sub-par in their country. I see it all the time for health care, roads, schools etc. I am simply providing an explanation that statistics indicates that there will be an absolute greater # of issues. I would also suggest that governing at scale is hard and doesn't seem to scale linearly; much worse, as far as I can guess, based upon my news reading. Things like population density, diversity of industry, diversity of cultures start to play out in a very loud and complicated way. The only person I've met (who I talked about this with) who appreciated the scale of the US immediately was from Russia, which has similar scale issues.
- grecy 14y agoAnd yet, Germany with ~80M seems to do just as well (if not better) than Australia with ~22M, or even New Zealand with ~4.5M. I didn't say it was easy, but I said it's something that should be in hand
- trhtrsh 14y agoThe 20th Century German model for unifying political dissent is not one to be emulated.
- tokipin 14y agoi think geography (namely, distance) is actually the fundamental issue here on top of geography, there is the issue that different states (in the U.S.) can have very different logistical/structural systems, different laws, different economic conditions, different budgets, etc
- jlgreco 14y agoIn the particular case of roads, the issue is actually that America does not have enough people for it's size. The population density in many states is too poor to support, at tax rates that americans are willing to tolerate, the amount of road that is necessary. See: the disparity between road quality in Maryland (good density) and Pennsylvania (poor density). (or, to correct for climate, compare Pennsylvania with New York).
- pulplobster 14y agoThe population density of Sweden is lower than the US and it has excellent roads.
- jlgreco 14y agoYes, that is true. The amount that the population is willing to be taxed is also an important factor however. I'm not saying that states with bad roads don't have themselves to blame, just that density is a factor.
- grecy 14y agoI said it's funny how Americans always use the big population excuse for having sub-par services. You're saying that it's got more to do with how much the population is willing to be taxed, which I believe is the real reason.
- jlgreco 14y agoYes, I agree with that. I guess what I'm saying is that while dodging the real cause of this issue, Americans are going to point to large geography rather than large population as the 'root cause'. In this case that isn't entirely without merit, since for a lot of Americans (those in Maryland for example) the '(tax rate * population) / area' equation works out alright.
- refurb 14y agoIt has less to do with population density and more to do with population clusters. The people in Sweden aren't even distributed across the entire country.