4 ms·
Suppose we stipulate that what you write is true. Does that good to society make up for the crippling costs and side effects of the very idea of ownership of i
by bediger4000 14y ago
Suppose we stipulate that what you write is true. Does that good to society make up for the crippling costs and side effects of the very idea of ownership of ideas, and the current implementation of "intellectual property"?
Just as an example, a really tight "intellectual property" regime would have to have laws banning unapproved operating systems (to prevent copying) and laws banning unapproved encryption (to prevent transferring "IP"). Maybe the encryption would have official backdoor keys to allow for inspection of encrypted data. Possession of encrypted data would possibly become criminal, too. Then there's the money price of enforcement, which won't be trivial.
Is all that worth it so we can have a MIPS?
- astrodust 14y agoSurely some form of copyright protection would apply to the actual design of the chip to prevent people from ripping it off wholesale. Would someone clean-room reimplementing a MIPS compatible chip be a bad thing, though? This isn't possible with patents.
- rayiner 14y agoCopyright protects only the most literal copying of a specific embodiment of a design. But when dealing with an embedded CPU, writing the VHDL isn't the hard part. The hard part is the circuit design. Compare this to a piece of enterprise software. The conceptual design is easy. Writing the 2 million lines of code is hard. Copyright works well for that.
- astrodust 14y agoIf all you had is a reference document on the instruction set, are you saying the hard part is already done? Or that the hard part would be figuring out how to implement that?
- rayiner 14y agoBut MIPS doesn't sell the instruction set reference. They sell CPU cores. So you have a blueprint that shows you exactly how the CPU works. The hard part is coming up with this blueprint, including things like designing caches to minimize power or structuring execution units to improve timing characteristics. That takes lots of expensive engineer time, iteration, testing, etc. But once all that information is distilled into a blueprint, it's relatively easy to actually implement it. Copyright protects you from literal copying of the blueprint. It doesn't protect you from someone just looking at your blueprint and implementing it. I used to work on military radios, and we spent millions of dollars and years developing our technology. The bulk of that investment was coming up with designs that worked well. We shipped customers reference code. Copyright kept the customer from copying the code itself, but didn't stop them from looking at how our code worked and writing their own version. But the code was the easy part--once you knew exactly what the code should do, it was a matter of 3-6 months of fairly straightforward coding to reproduce it without literally copying the code. It wasn't like say Windows where the hard part is literally reproducing all those 10 million lines of code.
- air 14y ago"It doesn't protect you from someone just looking at your blueprint and implementing it." I don't think this is true. You are creating a derived work, after all. Googling for blueprint and copyright shows that copyright disallows unauthorized implementation at least in the case of buildings.
- cwzwarich 14y agoMIPS also sells instruction set licenses if you want to build your own MIPS core from scratch.
- astrodust 14y agoThat's a somewhat valid point, but protecting that sort of innovation with patents is still extremely heavy handed. Just as software can be licensed with terms, surely these "blueprints" can be licensed with very specific regulations on how and where they can be used. Violating that agreement, which is very specific in nature, would be a lot more reasonable to enforce than what we have now. Those patents that've been sold off are most likely going to be used to shake-down other companies and lock out innovation. The most exploitable will be cherry picked, shunted into shell companies, and in time some jury in East Texas will have to make a decision on how many billions in damages need to be awarded.
- uvdiv 14y agoJust as an example, a really tight "intellectual property" regime would have to have... This is a logical fallacy: for an act to be illegal, it does not follow that the state is empowered to preempt it from ever occurring at all, especially at the expense of basic civil rights. Conspiracy to commit murder is illegal; yet most police forces don't read every piece of communication to make sure it isn't a murder plan. Domestic violence is a crime; yet there are not spouse-monitoring CCTV cameras in every household.
- bediger4000 14y agoOK, it's a logical fallacy, but you're splitting hairs. What's the point of "intellectual property" except to get some government to enforce it? "IP" laws don't empower individuals, in the way that say, free speech rights do. "IP" laws empower enforcers. So, yes, strictly speaking, I made a logical fallacy. In real life, that's the way "IP" is going to play out: strictly enforced.
- rayiner 14y agoWhat's the point of "real property" except to get some government to enforce it? That doesn't mean you need to enforce it as strictly as you can possibly imagine. By and large there is no government enforcement of patents--it's all left to private suits.
- bediger4000 14y agoYou can uniquely possess real property. That's actually what distinguishes "intellectual" from "real" property. The computer on which I type this is mine: I possess it solely. When I'm using it, nobody else can, there's simply no room o the keyboard. The same holds true for my other real property, my stove, my refridgerator, my toaster. You can use my "intellectual property" at exactly the same time and pretty much in exactly the same way as I use it. The law about "IP" is not about property per se, it's about monopoly. Some government agrees to enforce your monopoly on some idea.
- uvdiv 14y ago
- rayiner 14y agoLook, the "very ownership of ideas" rhetoric has a certain romantic appeal, but we allow people to own lots of things they didn't even create. The land under your house was there before you existed and will be there after you're dead, yet you're allowed to "own" it. We create property rights in various things because they are a useful way to structure social interaction. That's the only criteria for evaluation: usefulness. Romantic ideals have no place. As for your hypothetical example, who says the strongest possible intellectual property regime is the best one, and how does that imply that no intellectual property regime is the right answer? We certainly don't aggressively enforce other kinds of property rights. You can't sue someone if their dogs crap runs onto your yard when it rains, even though in theory you could define that as an infringement of your property right. We try to balance things. Enforce rights enough to give structure to human interaction without enforcing too much and stifling that interaction.
- bediger4000 14y agoI encourage you to look into the "moral rights" granted to creators under the Berne Convention, which the USA is a signatory (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights_%28copyright_law%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights_%28copyright_law%2...). If "usefulness" of a category of law is the absolute criteria, then we should have less "IP". Plenty of math, economics, and research shows that "IP" actually causes less use, less creation, and more problems.