6 ms·
Imagination buys MIPS for $60M, 498 patents sold to consortium for $350M
- rayiner 14y agoMIPS is a great example of the kind of tech company that wouldn't exist without some sort of intellectual property protection. They're specialists in chip design--they don't make any physical products. The whole value of their business is their designs, which are protected by their patent portfolio. In MIPS's case, intellectual property protection made it possible to compete on designing CPU's rather than designing finished products for those CPU's to go into. It allowed them to focus on chip design rather than fab design or manufacturing. And it allowed them to accumulate something of value in the company itself that could be sold later. Would CPU's get designed without patents? Of course. But I don't think the sort of beneficial division of labor you see with MIPS and ARM would be possible without some sort of intellectual property protection. When you can't easily transact in something, that forces you to try and move every operation involving that thing under one roof. And it's not hard to make the case that those kinds of monolithic companies are worse for competition than patent litigation.
- aristidb 14y agoYou can get those beneficial effects with trade secrets and NDAs, if _those_ are legally protected. All without a f*ing monopoly grant.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoIt is not practical to put an NDA on a mass marketed product.
- rayiner 14y agoTrade secrets can't be transacted in and NDA's don't protect against third parties. When you have hundreds of licensees, you can't bet the farm on all of them never accidentally or intentionally disclosing. Nobody would ever buy such a fragile property right. The "monopoly" aspect isn't really relevant here. It's not like you accidentally stumble onto a MIPS patent. If you're infringing it's because you're copying the design.
- ynniv 14y ago*The "monopoly" aspect isn't really relevant here. It's not If you're infringing it's because you're copying the design. Well that audacious. I'm will be less daring and say that with 500 patents, you are most certainly wrong about some of them. Last time I said this, you brought up a 60 year old RF parent, but I'll give you another shot and say that I hav never seen a software patent worth protecting.
- rayiner 14y agoThe RF patent was an example of the kind of patent I worked with, not a software patent specifically. My example for a software patent would be the h.264 patent. That's not something a practitioner of ordinary skill would find obvious.
- ismarc 14y agoThat's the entire f-ing point of patents. It's so they AREN'T kept as trade secrets. They are granted a monopoly in exchange for publication of it. It's the same reason the only prior art is something published, not a trade secret no one outside the company could have known about.
- victorlegros 14y agoTo carry on ismarc's thought, patents were only ever meant as a time-limited monopoly, to encourage and reward innovation. Patents and copyright have grown to become much more defense structures and "keep out" signs, which I think unfortunate, but the basic premise is sound.
- pcrh 14y agoFirst, patents are tradeable, NDAs are not. Second, trade secrets are only as secret as the people knowing them, which is not very secure. Third, if you have a patent, you can discuss the technology without NDAs, which helps both in getting the technology accepted as well as in early-stage business negotiations.
- rayiner 14y agoAlso, if anyone thinks getting rid of patents would get rid of litigstion, it wouldn't. An informal, ad-hoc patent like system would arise on top of NDA's and other contracts. Thse companies are always transacting with each other. Instead of suing Samsung for patent infringement, Apple would be suing for Samsung's copying Apple technology in violation of contractual obligations arising from Samsung's status as a supplier for Apple. Instead of patent litigstion in the ITC, we'd have litigstion over humongous iron clad contracts with suppliers in foreign countries.
- nickmain 14y agoYes - but such a system would be optional and small/open-source developers wouldn't be afraid to innovate.
- rayiner 14y agoSmall developers aren't immune to such activity. To the extent they do business with large companies, they can always be dragged in as co-defendants. "Apple: Samsung stole our technology and gave it to LittleCo, who were are suing separately for tortious interference with a contract." The point is that if there really are so many entities just trying to abuse the system, they don't need patents to do it.
- pcrh 14y agoSmall developers are best protected by patents, which simplifies using the judicial system to enforce their rights. Otherwise they would have to use a more messy system of contracts, as rayiner describes.
- bediger4000 14y agoSuppose we stipulate that what you write is true. Does that good to society make up for the crippling costs and side effects of the very idea of ownership of ideas, and the current implementation of "intellectual property"? Just as an example, a really tight "intellectual property" regime would have to have laws banning unapproved operating systems (to prevent copying) and laws banning unapproved encryption (to prevent transferring "IP"). Maybe the encryption would have official backdoor keys to allow for inspection of encrypted data. Possession of encrypted data would possibly become criminal, too. Then there's the money price of enforcement, which won't be trivial. Is all that worth it so we can have a MIPS?
- astrodust 14y agoSurely some form of copyright protection would apply to the actual design of the chip to prevent people from ripping it off wholesale. Would someone clean-room reimplementing a MIPS compatible chip be a bad thing, though? This isn't possible with patents.
- rayiner 14y agoCopyright protects only the most literal copying of a specific embodiment of a design. But when dealing with an embedded CPU, writing the VHDL isn't the hard part. The hard part is the circuit design. Compare this to a piece of enterprise software. The conceptual design is easy. Writing the 2 million lines of code is hard. Copyright works well for that.
- astrodust 14y agoIf all you had is a reference document on the instruction set, are you saying the hard part is already done? Or that the hard part would be figuring out how to implement that?
- rayiner 14y agoBut MIPS doesn't sell the instruction set reference. They sell CPU cores. So you have a blueprint that shows you exactly how the CPU works. The hard part is coming up with this blueprint, including things like designing caches to minimize power or structuring execution units to improve timing characteristics. That takes lots of expensive engineer time, iteration, testing, etc. But once all that information is distilled into a blueprint, it's relatively easy to actually implement it. Copyright protects you from literal copying of the blueprint. It doesn't protect you from someone just looking at your blueprint and implementing it. I used to work on military radios, and we spent millions of dollars and years developing our technology. The bulk of that investment was coming up with designs that worked well. We shipped customers reference code. Copyright kept the customer from copying the code itself, but didn't stop them from looking at how our code worked and writing their own version. But the code was the easy part--once you knew exactly what the code should do, it was a matter of 3-6 months of fairly straightforward coding to reproduce it without literally copying the code. It wasn't like say Windows where the hard part is literally reproducing all those 10 million lines of code.
- artsrc 14y agoThere are many examples of a division of labor between companies without intellectual property protection being involved. I have worked on many consulting projects where intellectual property protection of the results was not significant. So for example MIPS could become a CPU design consulting company to fab companies that want to produce chips. It seems to me that this would reduce barriers to entry and improve allocation of resources.
- xradionut 14y agoJust wish I had more choices of small MIPS based boards and computers like I do with ARM.
- dbloom 14y agoThe vast majority of Wi-Fi routers are MIPS-based. They're inexpensive, widely available, and have have a vibrant developer community. They are cost-competitive with single-board ARM computers, especially when you consider that they include enclosures and many network interfaces. I wouldn't be surprised if far more people have SSH'd into their router's shell than have bought Raspberry Pi's.
- xradionut 14y agoAny recommended statrting points? LinuxMips wiki is very informative, but not very helpful...
- mtgx 14y agoSeeing how tightly they control their GPU drivers for Linux, future Imagination "SoC's" probably won't be very compelling for Linux users.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoInteresting that imagination is pursuing the CPU + gpu one stop shop like arm/Mali