4 ms·
The counterpoint to this message was shared by a friend of mine on Facebook (he is a high-tech company manager) right after it was published. "Your Vote Doesn't
by tokenadult 14y ago
The counterpoint to this message was shared by a friend of mine on Facebook (he is a high-tech company manager) right after it was published. "Your Vote Doesn't Count:
Why (almost) everyone should stay home on Election Day"
http://reason.com/archives/2012/10/03/your-vote-doesnt-count http://reason.com/archives/2012/10/03/your-vote-doesnt-count
didn't convince me (I'll be voting today), but both the mathematics and the political science in this article are interesting for rationales for NOT voting.
Vote or not as you wish. As Winston Churchill said, "Many forms of Government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time."
AFTER EDIT: Today's news includes an analysis of why voter turnout in the United States is only around 60 percent of persons eligible to be voters,
http://news.yahoo.com/why-40-americans-wont-vote-president-231957289.html http://news.yahoo.com/why-40-americans-wont-vote-president-2...
a lower percentage than in some other democratic republics.
Thanks for the first comment received below this one, which points out that local elections can matter for voters as well as the presidential election. I have some very close races to vote in today in the state Legislature and on proposed amendments to the state constitution.
- duck 14y agoWhy (almost) everyone should stay home on Election Day The problem with that reasoning is that you're not just voting for the next president, but usually on a local ballot as well which is OFTEN very close. Government really is a local thing, although we often miss that, so I think every election is an important one.
- zerostar07 14y agoThat article seems to grossly ridicule the motives of voters. Voters don't have to be either vanity freaks who think their vote will change the outcome or deluded armchair altruists. What if people simply vote because not only most others do, but because they want to weigh in their modest (even ill-informed) opinion. History shows it's the best way to figure out who should run an office.
- sdoering 14y agoI can only talk for the German system here. But I looked at the numbers and calculated, that there is no reason for me to vote. My individual vote does not change anything, but gives the mainstream-parties money for their campaigns. As I firmly do not believe in their agenda, I try not to compensate them. I was once a party member, and having seen their inner workings disgusted me and robbed me of everything, I believed to be true in an democracy. So giving money to them by voting is something, I cannot square with my conscience. But we have a different political system here. And there are some interesting ideas on the theoretical ROI of voting in different US-States. So the situation might be very different for you. From a German, totally subjective, perspective, I really hope, that Obama wins. But either way, I do not believe, that the outcome of the ballot really changes a lot (on a global scale). Lobbyists will push legislation, firms will try to make money and the world will turn to another day tomorrow. War will be the way to secure some national agendas and poor or middle class people will try to make a living.
- zerostar07 14y agoWell, if a substantial percentage of voters thinks this way, maybe democracy has run its course. After all, sovereign democracies haven't changed much since the french revolution. Personally, i find rising trends like libertarianism rather frightening though. BTW, i'm not american, i'm greek so i know what a broken democracy looks like. I 'm split on the US election; was disappointed by obama so far to be honest.
- sdoering 14y agoWell my goal was to determine, when the radical right parties would have a seat in parliament. I detected, that really an unrealistic lot of people would have to stay at home. I wanted to debunk the popular argument, that the one who does not vote, votes for the extreme parties.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoHistory shows it's the best way to figure out who should run an office. How so? Incidentally, even if we treat voting as some weird "wisdom of crowds, all of our uninformed opinions put together is better than any of the individual ones" thing, we can also conclude that your vote doesn't matter much. Suppose the election is close, in which case your vote might actually matter. We can then conclude the "wisdom of crowds" declared Romney and Obama to be nearly equally good, in which case the gain from choosing the better candidate is very small.