3 ms·
The paper on which the article is based, https://watermark02.silverchair.com/stag328.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAA1YwggNSBgkq
by purplejacket 6mo ago
The paper on which the article is based,
https://watermark02.silverchair.com/stag328.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAA1YwggNSBgkqhkiG9w0BBwagggNDMIIDPwIBADCCAzgGCSqGSIb3DQEHATAeBglghkgBZQMEAS4wEQQM5SK0P0H4LB8k3KnLAgEQgIIDCd-y15FimTxce-v_9jlrSyjAfdknm1QjI6DuOreaiG2EejhnhBzPzTjJTTn6Fb2gW-XDnk-LagSUCTWDYjN7e9wkGG-b_eAPAlicRCj-N0aNQy6gMeTlTF4nba_nB33WL8kNYFubur8lnxDRrjhOEgs3i6jGeMVUAhwSc0_b-j9kG8ogLubEpB1y3S7pUf9DKn0Te6cuGXjc_ZbLNtyReGpJzmD1IYzNa-vEk5xmb2_Drwo5CSuL9F0nryIrVLLTQL-v6CV7ng0qDwrhdc9oPgVXiolrBMlbiuFMpdvQ3g-oA2Ih6Ez8dR4VgRkq_d8O67l8RWVK_Mc4aSFNpWpBJmOymPUJyKWkxFmEJ6JS5MDg5qMVC4SpWiME_TtywWgBeXQ1UQ1UNvYQ0_--2KHmUECTV96xVVw5zHRWpICL7-LENuh67ai4ulI1r7QVP-mjqmQec3oti0ohuJybh5ebQOwMdh09TatNaJHclily_swgTh-UUq-_K2J3VDuRq-pahNfOvhYS_EO3Ok-E44Vbo1quWWY1brQ91mjA4nxHp3j3uTYUrxxkI_WzqloPqGdzXYeeDCWpTRsGxlzWTtTn1WA__AjH34J0PtKqFUbJ1xfV97TTvV1CDIK4PXW-L-JYQzDqYrAakoDrZZzzWeHeiv67YQWAY5i76Ifnn7LWNkyl1_aYObFxY0Lh0ZQrVlMNuDBu2hCpzUL6GRA0uguzGXDETjNX3wbEIMRqRYRdrOKB-NmEvnIjZ13iXdQLwQTJ57rstJiMcGb60YIGM-B0iBl4cGrlHWZSe7ZGtmxXrHna58MAXQdpQVKdmQmf00H04dVWuRIgd00GfMnPp4MXR-j_GAsuRXW_zPZkP11jOQwpuv2hIEY7azfbTvK2jiRM9NXABa1zAb5DwopvsFp5OSyZEwSa7log-y603bRIUZJ7IoW0pD5UXkMbo6da1QWKK0-IDZDecVpaww9WVwlyY1Co36Jb2qQi4bYtRSYZN8HgGjn_DJtVDCseTmte5JbtEuu2-soH_aRXiQ https://watermark02.silverchair.com/stag328.pdf?token=AQECAH...
mentions 3 three alternative interpretations for GRB 250702B:
1. Ultralong Collapsars: These stellar-engine models can explain long durations but struggle to account for the specific timing of this event. Specifically, they cannot easily produce a 12-hour gradual rise in X-rays followed by a multi-hour peak, as the jet would have to fight through a massive progenitor star while its power is still very low.
2. White Dwarf (WD) Tidal Disruptions: While an Intermediate Mass Black Hole (IMBH) disrupting a White Dwarf could theoretically provide the necessary gravity, the numbers do not add up for this specific burst. The timing between flares is too long for a WD scenario, and the total energy required would demand an unrealistically narrow jet. When physical constraints like detonation are factored in, this model is considered highly unlikely.
3. Micro-TDEs (Main Sequence star by a stellar-mass BH/NS): This is considered a competitive alternative that can explain the burst's sub-second variability and long duration. However, it faces two main issues: current afterglow data suggests the surrounding gas density matches an IMBH environment better than a micro-TDE environment, and the burst’s extreme energy would require very high jet efficiency or a very narrow beam.