3 ms·
It's hard to escape the fact that "crowdsourced" == "gameable". My current local demonstration of the pointlessness of crowdsourced reviews: http://www.urbans
by bigiain 14y ago
It's hard to escape the fact that "crowdsourced" == "gameable".
My current local demonstration of the pointlessness of crowdsourced reviews:
http://www.urbanspoon.com/r/71/1709549/restaurant/Melbourne/St-Ali-North-Carlton-North http://www.urbanspoon.com/r/71/1709549/restaurant/Melbourne/...
A cafe that's not open yet, has 9 votes including 2 "I didn't like it" votes.
It's interesting that St Ali's other café seems to have a string of recent poor reviews (many written in a suspiciously similar style). Surely it'd be easy for UrbanSpoon to do a quick "sanity check", identify the 9 voters who've voted on a venue they couldn't possibly have been to to form a valid opinion, then remove all their votes and reviews across the board?
That's what _I'd_ do if my objective was a fair and balanced review site. Of course if my objective was a Yelp-like advertising service using poor reviews as a way to blackmail small businesses into paying protection/advertising, I'd obviously _welcome_ poor reviews and vindictive downvotes for businesses that haven't even opened yet… UrbanSpoon, like Yelp, is clearly signalling their intentions to me, and calibrating my expectations of their usefulness...