5 ms·
I agree with what you're saying, but I think more important than any issue is sending the message to politicians that if they do stupid things, they don't get t
by notatoad 14y ago
I agree with what you're saying, but I think more important than any issue is sending the message to politicians that if they do stupid things, they don't get to stay in office. Get rid of the moron who voted for SOPA, and vote in the moron who hates women. Then, two years later, vote him out. He won't have had a chance to do any damage yet, and we'll have sent the message to Minnesota politicians that neither of their positions were tolerable.
(disclaimer: i do not live in the US, and i don't vote in elections in my home country. i'm just talking out of my ass here)
- rhizome 14y agoThis is a great point that I have been struggling with for some months now: "change" is a perfectly valid vote. In software development terms, it's reasonable to think the government is suffering from a lack of iteration.
- scarmig 14y agoEh, I think that analogy falls flat. Both sides want "change," and both sides broadly want change taken from their respective playbooks in the 2000s, the 1990s, and even the 1980s. What makes politics difficult isn't that people don't want to iterate on government, but that people have radically different product visions. One wants to make an enterprise CRM, and the other wants to make a microblogging site for cats. That naturally leads to massive dysfunction, as you end up somewhere in the middle and people cynically playing cough politics for internal advancement since everyone's stuck in the same place with no hope for real vision or resolution.
- pessimizer 14y ago>Eh, I think that analogy falls flat. Both sides want "change," Rhetorical change, maybe; they're also for tradition, security, the heartland, and babies. Changing from an incumbent to a challenger is actual change, and no party is in support of that except in the specific cases that benefit their own candidates.
- rhizome 14y agoWe don't know what "people" want, but I do think that to whatever degree we can find such things out, we probably have a higher degree of confidence that the government doesn't want to iterate on the people who comprise it. The revolving door is a highly-valued feature in DC. That's what voting against incumbents threatens.
- anigbrowl 14y agoThat might make sense if we didn't have such a divided government.
- rhizome 14y agoSuch division is a symptom of the status quo. Change the people and you introduce more noise into the system and divisions break down.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI'm not sure that your conclusion necessarily follows from your premise. We got a bunch of new people (mainly tea Party types) at the last Congressional election and if anything they've been more obstructive than the 111th Congress.
- rhizome 14y agoIt may take more than one election cycle.
- eli 14y agoThen you should work to make this a common option in the United States: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/None_of_the_above http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/None_of_the_above You should not arbitrarily vote for candidates who do not match your beliefs as part of some sort of protest.
- GFischer 14y agoThat does send a message, but I haven't seen it being effective yet. Over here, we have a very bad municipal government, so when elections came, with a bad officialist candidate that was called a "fridge" and divided opposition, over 15% voted "none". So far, it hasn't had much of an effect (though the governing party has taken note of it, for the next elections).
- dllthomas 14y ago> Then, two years later, vote him out. In the senate, it's 6 years.
- anigbrowl 14y agoHe won't have had a chance to do any damage yet What makes you think that?
- eli 14y agoThis is a truly terrible idea. I am not sure what message you think it will send or even who the message is supposed to be directed towards. You should vote for the best candidate.
- jacoblyles 14y agoWho's the moron who hates women? If you are saying that because he is pro-life, then most women hate women because more women in America identify with "pro-life" than "pro-choice" when given the option.
- rorrr 14y agoPeople vote against their own interests all the time. Women aren't an exception. This particular issue exists purely because of the religion, which is still prevalent in the country.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIt's not a religious thing - plenty of atheistic limousine liberals vote against their own self interest. Most scientists also vote D, even though voting R is the best way to increase scientific funding. There are plenty of people in the bottom 47% (predominantly tax consumers) who vote R and in the top 53% (predominantly taxpayers) who vote D. Are they all doing it purely because of religion? If you look around, you'll see lots of people voting for reasons other than self interest.
- dbaupp 14y agoYour scientist example isn't very good. Scientists have self interest that extends beyond just getting more funding for their work.
- barry-cotter 14y agoYes, and everybody else on that list has values which they allow to override their narrow pecuniary self interest too.
- johnpowell 14y agoWell, they will probably shift pretty fast once some RIAA money trickles in. I care a lot more about my daughters right to be in control of her reproductive health than I do about people downloading the new Jay-Z single for free.
- itistoday2 14y agoHeh, supposing the politician isn't re-elected, do you think the reason for it is even knowable? There could be 50 other single-issue voters who voted them out for various different reasons, or a variety of other possibilities.