4 ms·

> limited by no "platforms" but only by their own lack of desire. Or Google's low ranking of their content

by throwaway0q5347 7mo ago

lstodd 7mo ago
I don't even. Relying on third-party ranking of whatever is a clear indicator of lack of effort.
- StableAlkyne 7mo ago
  Short of developing psychic abilities, how would you then address the discoverability problem without relying on a third party? Forums, search engines, social media, and link aggregators are all third parties with their own ranking. Nobody outside of a handful of small-web hobbyists have put a "cool links" section into a website since 1997.
  - skydhash 7mo ago
    There’s always a relationship aspect in discoverability. Unless the set is small, there will always be intermediary nodes in that graph that will connect consumers and producers. But there’s no need for it to be a mega tech company. Radio DJs help with discovering musics. Books club can help with recommending books.
    - johnnyanmac 7mo ago
      Doesn't need to be, but most traffic is driven by search. I reckon 2nd most common is influencers, and I don't know if that's an upgrade (even easier to buy out).
  - BowBun 7mo ago
    This is classic engineering missing the forest for the trees. The answer to your question is: same as we always did before! Do you talk to friends? Colleagues? Family? You definitely chat with us here on HN. All of these people share things with you constantly. There's a funny obsession in tech circles to gather all the information they can as quick as possible. I much prefer to optimize for the quality of information I'm ingesting.
    - thaumasiotes 7mo ago
      > The answer to your question is: same as we always did before! Do you talk to friends? Colleagues? Family? You definitely chat with us here on HN. All of these people share things with you constantly. So, in your opinion, we can cut out the reliance on third parties by relying on third parties?

> limited by no "platforms" but only by their own lack of desire. Or Google's low ranking of their content

lstodd 7mo ago

I don't even. Relying on third-party ranking of whatever is a clear indicator of lack of effort.

StableAlkyne 7mo ago
Short of developing psychic abilities, how would you then address the discoverability problem without relying on a third party? Forums, search engines, social media, and link aggregators are all third parties with their own ranking. Nobody outside of a handful of small-web hobbyists have put a "cool links" section into a website since 1997.
- skydhash 7mo ago
  There’s always a relationship aspect in discoverability. Unless the set is small, there will always be intermediary nodes in that graph that will connect consumers and producers. But there’s no need for it to be a mega tech company. Radio DJs help with discovering musics. Books club can help with recommending books.
  - johnnyanmac 7mo ago
    Doesn't need to be, but most traffic is driven by search. I reckon 2nd most common is influencers, and I don't know if that's an upgrade (even easier to buy out).
- BowBun 7mo ago
  This is classic engineering missing the forest for the trees. The answer to your question is: same as we always did before! Do you talk to friends? Colleagues? Family? You definitely chat with us here on HN. All of these people share things with you constantly. There's a funny obsession in tech circles to gather all the information they can as quick as possible. I much prefer to optimize for the quality of information I'm ingesting.
  - thaumasiotes 7mo ago
    > The answer to your question is: same as we always did before! Do you talk to friends? Colleagues? Family? You definitely chat with us here on HN. All of these people share things with you constantly. So, in your opinion, we can cut out the reliance on third parties by relying on third parties?