3 ms·

> Why did they ban combustion vehicles? Because they have no domestic fossil fuel supplies and the import cost was crushing them Your closing argument is that

> Why did they ban combustion vehicles? Because they have no domestic fossil fuel supplies and the import cost was crushing them Your closing argument is that some far away land with no nat gas / oil reserves of their own isn’t convincing anyone with nat gas / oil reserves of their own. Europeans need inexpensive fuels to power their existing fleet or vehicles now. Ethiopia’s plan doesn’t generalise.

toomuchtodo 7mo ago
Europe has no choice but to lean into low carbon generation and EVs now, their hand is forced by geopolitical energy events outside of their control. These options are objectively cheaper than attempting to develop new domestic fossil resources. China will build every cheap EV Europe will buy if the EU cannot build them fast enough (citations on EU EV sales are in my comment you replied to), so buy them or experience economic pain and ongoing energy inflation from choosing to continue to burn fossil fuels for energy. These are straightforward choices to make. The clean energy path is the cheaper path, based on all available data as of this comment. (from your profile, "They force us to use extremely expensive renewable energy to run our energy efficient extremely disposable appliances," so I'm unsure how effective facts and data will be in this discussion, but I am trying very hard to share the relevant facts as a shared foundation to discuss from) Citations: Germany's Solar Boom Eases Power Costs as Gas Price Jumps - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47323028 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47323028 - March 2026 Lazard LCOE+ 2025 [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47184980 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47184980 - March 2026 Wind power slashed 4.6B euros off electricity bills in Spain last year - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46622463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46622463 - January 2026 France's 2024 Power Grid Was 95% Fossil Free as Nuclear, Renewables Jumped - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42770556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42770556 - January 2025
- nandomrumber 7mo ago
  > Europe has no choice I’ve been following you for 13 years in this site, and I really expect more intellectually honest comments from you. You’re trying to tell us that developing new battery technology, new storage technology, deploying more wind / solar and replacing the entire European vehicle fleet, is cheaper than building new oil / gas infrastructure. I’m not buying it. Regarding the comment in my profile, I’ve done warranty repair work on home appliances. Some manufacturers have moved to assembly methods that render appliances uneconomical to repair, or impractical. Also, in Australia, electricity price increases have been double or triple that of general inflation. The comment in my profile is an objective assessment of the facts, not an ideological screed.
  - deleted 7mo ago
    [deleted]
  - toomuchtodo 7mo ago
    > I’ve been following you for 13 years in this site, and I really expect more intellectually honest comments from you. I believe the failure is on your part, not my part, as I am simply providing facts. Whether you agree with facts is beyond my control. They remain facts. You keep stating, inaccurately, that renewables and batteries are expensive, when they are the cheapest combined generation technology. This is widely proven, and again, I am sorry if for whatever reason you are ignoring that fact. > Also, in Australia, electricity price increases have been double or triple that of general inflation. The facts do not align with your assertion. I have provided citations below to assist you in updating your mental model on the price and carbon intensity trajectory of the Australian power markets. Power prices expected to fall by up to 10% from July, bringing ‘welcome relief’ to Australia’s east coast - https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/mar/19/power-bills-on-australias-east-coast-expected-to-fall-by-up-to-10-from-july-bringing-welcome-relief https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/mar/19/power... - March 19th, 2026 > Power prices on Australia’s east coast are predicted to fall from July because of increased output from wind generation and batteries, and falling electricity contract prices, with potential savings up to $1,320 for some small businesses. In a draft decision on Thursday, the Australia Energy Regulator (AER) proposed a price reduction for customers on standing electricity plans – known as the “default market offer” – of between 1.3% to 10.1% for residential customers, and between 8.5% and 21.2% for small businesses, depending on the region. Savage said reduced wholesale prices were the “biggest driver” behind the draft decision for 2026-27. “We’ve had lots more renewables come into the market. We’ve had good wind, solar and battery performance.” The draft determination also introduces the “solar sharer” offer, an opt-in plan that includes three hours of free power in the middle of the day to take advantage of abundant solar energy. The energy minister, Chris Bowen, said the idea was designed to share the benefits of Australia’s solar success. “For households that can shift some of their usage into the free power period, this can mean real savings on bills, whether that is running the dishwasher, doing the washing, or heating hot water during the day.” Solar is so cheap and plentiful (as there is not yet enough battery storage on the network to time shift this power), they plan to give it away for free for ~3 hours/day in parts of the Australian NEM system. Australia's renewables boom delivers coveted power price payoff - https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/australias-renewables-boom-delivers-coveted-power-price-payoff-2026-02-10/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/australias-renew... - February 10th, 2026 ("Australia's wholesale electricity prices fell to the lowest in four years in 2025, bucking the rising price trends seen elsewhere and validating claims that renewables-heavy power system overhauls can help lower consumer power costs.") Near 100 pct renewable electricity for Australia’s main grid is achievable and affordable: Year 4 update - https://reneweconomy.com.au/near-100-pct-renewable-electricity-for-australias-main-grid-is-achievable-and-affordable-year-4-update/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/near-100-pct-renewable-electrici... - January 29th, 2026 Big batteries oust gas in ‘transformational’ grid overhaul - https://www.afr.com/policy/energy-and-climate/big-batteries-oust-gas-in-transformational-grid-overhaul-20260121-p5nvvv https://www.afr.com/policy/energy-and-climate/big-batteries-... - January 26th, 2026 Australia becomes world’s third-largest utility battery market - https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/10/21/australia-becomes-worlds-third-largest-utility-battery-market/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/10/21/australia-becomes-wor... - October 21st, 2025 Further data can confirm this at https://openelectricity.org.au/ https://openelectricity.org.au/ (which has both carbon intensity and price data for all Australian electrical grids except the Northern Territory)
- slashdev 7mo ago
  I am 100% bullish on both solar energy and EVs, and I share your optimism around the technology. But I think you're being too optimistic about what this means for global fossil fuel usage. Definitely over the next decade, but potentially over much longer periods than that.

toomuchtodo 7mo ago

Europe has no choice but to lean into low carbon generation and EVs now, their hand is forced by geopolitical energy events outside of their control. These options are objectively cheaper than attempting to develop new domestic fossil resources. China will build every cheap EV Europe will buy if the EU cannot build them fast enough (citations on EU EV sales are in my comment you replied to), so buy them or experience economic pain and ongoing energy inflation from choosing to continue to burn fossil fuels for energy. These are straightforward choices to make. The clean energy path is the cheaper path, based on all available data as of this comment. (from your profile, "They force us to use extremely expensive renewable energy to run our energy efficient extremely disposable appliances," so I'm unsure how effective facts and data will be in this discussion, but I am trying very hard to share the relevant facts as a shared foundation to discuss from) Citations: Germany's Solar Boom Eases Power Costs as Gas Price Jumps - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47323028 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47323028 - March 2026 Lazard LCOE+ 2025 [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47184980 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47184980 - March 2026 Wind power slashed 4.6B euros off electricity bills in Spain last year - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46622463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46622463 - January 2026 France's 2024 Power Grid Was 95% Fossil Free as Nuclear, Renewables Jumped - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42770556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42770556 - January 2025

nandomrumber 7mo ago
> Europe has no choice I’ve been following you for 13 years in this site, and I really expect more intellectually honest comments from you. You’re trying to tell us that developing new battery technology, new storage technology, deploying more wind / solar and replacing the entire European vehicle fleet, is cheaper than building new oil / gas infrastructure. I’m not buying it. Regarding the comment in my profile, I’ve done warranty repair work on home appliances. Some manufacturers have moved to assembly methods that render appliances uneconomical to repair, or impractical. Also, in Australia, electricity price increases have been double or triple that of general inflation. The comment in my profile is an objective assessment of the facts, not an ideological screed.
- deleted 7mo ago
  [deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7mo ago
  > I’ve been following you for 13 years in this site, and I really expect more intellectually honest comments from you. I believe the failure is on your part, not my part, as I am simply providing facts. Whether you agree with facts is beyond my control. They remain facts. You keep stating, inaccurately, that renewables and batteries are expensive, when they are the cheapest combined generation technology. This is widely proven, and again, I am sorry if for whatever reason you are ignoring that fact. > Also, in Australia, electricity price increases have been double or triple that of general inflation. The facts do not align with your assertion. I have provided citations below to assist you in updating your mental model on the price and carbon intensity trajectory of the Australian power markets. Power prices expected to fall by up to 10% from July, bringing ‘welcome relief’ to Australia’s east coast - https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/mar/19/power-bills-on-australias-east-coast-expected-to-fall-by-up-to-10-from-july-bringing-welcome-relief https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2026/mar/19/power... - March 19th, 2026 > Power prices on Australia’s east coast are predicted to fall from July because of increased output from wind generation and batteries, and falling electricity contract prices, with potential savings up to $1,320 for some small businesses. In a draft decision on Thursday, the Australia Energy Regulator (AER) proposed a price reduction for customers on standing electricity plans – known as the “default market offer” – of between 1.3% to 10.1% for residential customers, and between 8.5% and 21.2% for small businesses, depending on the region. Savage said reduced wholesale prices were the “biggest driver” behind the draft decision for 2026-27. “We’ve had lots more renewables come into the market. We’ve had good wind, solar and battery performance.” The draft determination also introduces the “solar sharer” offer, an opt-in plan that includes three hours of free power in the middle of the day to take advantage of abundant solar energy. The energy minister, Chris Bowen, said the idea was designed to share the benefits of Australia’s solar success. “For households that can shift some of their usage into the free power period, this can mean real savings on bills, whether that is running the dishwasher, doing the washing, or heating hot water during the day.” Solar is so cheap and plentiful (as there is not yet enough battery storage on the network to time shift this power), they plan to give it away for free for ~3 hours/day in parts of the Australian NEM system. Australia's renewables boom delivers coveted power price payoff - https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/australias-renewables-boom-delivers-coveted-power-price-payoff-2026-02-10/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/australias-renew... - February 10th, 2026 ("Australia's wholesale electricity prices fell to the lowest in four years in 2025, bucking the rising price trends seen elsewhere and validating claims that renewables-heavy power system overhauls can help lower consumer power costs.") Near 100 pct renewable electricity for Australia’s main grid is achievable and affordable: Year 4 update - https://reneweconomy.com.au/near-100-pct-renewable-electricity-for-australias-main-grid-is-achievable-and-affordable-year-4-update/ https://reneweconomy.com.au/near-100-pct-renewable-electrici... - January 29th, 2026 Big batteries oust gas in ‘transformational’ grid overhaul - https://www.afr.com/policy/energy-and-climate/big-batteries-oust-gas-in-transformational-grid-overhaul-20260121-p5nvvv https://www.afr.com/policy/energy-and-climate/big-batteries-... - January 26th, 2026 Australia becomes world’s third-largest utility battery market - https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/10/21/australia-becomes-worlds-third-largest-utility-battery-market/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/10/21/australia-becomes-wor... - October 21st, 2025 Further data can confirm this at https://openelectricity.org.au/ https://openelectricity.org.au/ (which has both carbon intensity and price data for all Australian electrical grids except the Northern Territory)
slashdev 7mo ago
I am 100% bullish on both solar energy and EVs, and I share your optimism around the technology. But I think you're being too optimistic about what this means for global fossil fuel usage. Definitely over the next decade, but potentially over much longer periods than that.