3 ms·
A decade ago I figured we be at 10ghz by now, didn't count on more cores instead of faster. Of course you cannot compare 1ghz in 2003 to 1ghz in 2013, way more
by ck2 14y ago
A decade ago I figured we be at 10ghz by now, didn't count on more cores instead of faster.
Of course you cannot compare 1ghz in 2003 to 1ghz in 2013, way more efficient per clock cycle with the right code.
- GotAnyMegadeth 14y agoA decade ago I figured we be at 100 cores by now, didn't count on using quantum computing instead of adding more cores. Of course you cannot compare 10 cores in 2013 to 10 cores in 2023, way more efficient per core with the right code.
- marshray 14y agoBut we are well over 100 cores right now ... on GPUs. Yes, they're sort of different animals. This is what change looks like. Our intuition can be correct yet we still have to be open enough to recognize it when we it actually happens. OTOH, quantum computers continue to not ship as a product.
- wmf 14y agoNot really; GPUs have have hundreds of "cores" but only 8-16 cores.
- bunderbunder 14y ago> didn't count on using quantum computing instead of adding more cores. And you probably still shouldn't. Quantum computing only provides a speedup for a very specific set of problems. For the vast majority of everyday computing tasks, quantum computing offers no practical advantage over classical computing.
- dillona 14y agoUnfortunately with clock speeds, we wind up bumping up against fundamental laws of physics. At 10Ghz, something moving at the speed of light can only go around 3 centimeters per clock cycle. Take out gate delays, and you wind up with something that just isn't practical.
- ck2 14y agoYou're thinking 2-dimensionally ;-) Our future CPUs should be tiny cubes, not flat chips. Distance to each point in 3 dimensions is shorter.
- miahi 14y agoYou cannot efficiently cool a cubical CPU.
- lovamova 14y agoMaybe it won't need cooling.
- xtc 14y agoNot yet.
- powertower 14y agonanotubes
- dsr_ 14y agoTake eight chips. Stack them, insert spacers and bridges from top to bottom, and connect them via BGA or pins or what-have-you on the very top and very bottom chips. Now turn them sideways, so they rest on the edges. Put the stack in a small ceramic container with copper bottom and top. Fill with a high efficiency thermal transfer fluid, and make sure the convection currents flow properly. There you go, small matter of engineering.
- miahi 14y agoThis defeats the "shorter distance in a cube" issue.
- mbell 14y agoCPUs are already 3 dimensional, the 'wiring' connecting the transistors is often several layers think.
- bunderbunder 14y agoI suspect that even just looking at single-core performance it would be hard to make a 10GHz CPU that approaches what we're doing with 3GHz nowadays. Take Pentium 4 - which used the architecture Intel was working on when they were predicting that they'd have 10GHz CPUs by now. Passmark's score for a 3GHz Pentium 4 is 384. An i7-3940XM runs at 3GHz, and gets a score of 10,490. That's a quad-core computer, so I'm going to go ahead and be sloppy by dividing by 4 to get a score of 2622.5 per core. In other words, a single i7 core is doing almost seven times as much work per clock cycle. And assuming they only ramped up the clock rate, the P4 would have to be running at over 20GHz to match what the i7 is doing on a per-core basis. Given the heat dissipation problems that come into play with high clock rates, that seems like a doubtful proposition. In hindsight, it looks like Intel definitely made the right choice by dumping the NetBurst plan and instead letting clock rates stagnate (they've even retracted a bit from the high water mark) while designing the processor core to do a lot more with each cycle.
- 0xABADC0DA 14y ago> P4 would have to be running at over 20GHz to match what the i7 is doing on a per-core basis. Seems to me memory getting 10x more bandwidth and cache getting 8x larger probably accounts for the majority of the performance differences between these processors not instructions per cycle, which I think has gone up by more like 2x. So a Pentium 4 with current memory and cache would need to be more like 8 Ghz if it scaled linearly like that (P4 had ~3 instructions per cycle, i7 ~7-8). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instructions_per_second http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instructions_per_second