4 ms·

Anthropic are masters in marketing to make people think they’re here to do good. A few weeks ago, they got great visibility on HN promising Claude Max 20x accou

Anthropic are masters in marketing to make people think they’re here to do good. A few weeks ago, they got great visibility on HN promising Claude Max 20x accounts to people who are active in open source repositories with at least 5k stars on GitHub [1]. My main project [2] has more than double the minimum requirements, and I’m still waiting. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47178371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47178371 [2] https://github.com/mickael-kerjean/filestash https://github.com/mickael-kerjean/filestash

fasterik 7mo ago
Humans are complex. It's possible for someone to want to do good and at the same time want to promote/market their product and make a profit. I don't see a contradiction there.
- mickael-kerjean 7mo ago
  How do you call a marketing campaign that does not deliver on what it promised? I have no problem with anthropic trying to create good will around their products but this particular campain aiming to find good will around people doing open source was an outright lie that did not deliver what it promised and this was all done on HN. When a company lies for something that trivial, it does not inspire trust
  - fasterik 7mo ago
    It's an outright lie because they haven't greenlit your personal project after two weeks? Did it occur to you that maybe they just got a lot of applications and are prioritizing other projects or still working through a backlog?
  - 3371 7mo ago
    They would be 100% lying if they have infinite budget allocated to this campaign and haven't approved all requests.
benterix 7mo ago
I just checked your projects, it looks just like something I was looking for. And I hope in a few weeks the guys from Anthropic will give you what they promised. However, since we're frank here, I'd say I'll download the most recent release and be very careful about upgrading because I don't put much trust in projects co-created with LLMs. I know there is a full spectrum but I've seen enough and I don't have the resources to check where on the spectrum your project ends up. LLMs are a powerful drug and terribly hard to stop once you start.
- mickael-kerjean 7mo ago
  > I don't put much trust in projects co-created with LLMs Its not, there is history since 2017 and I've been working on this full time

fasterik 7mo ago

Humans are complex. It's possible for someone to want to do good and at the same time want to promote/market their product and make a profit. I don't see a contradiction there.

mickael-kerjean 7mo ago
How do you call a marketing campaign that does not deliver on what it promised? I have no problem with anthropic trying to create good will around their products but this particular campain aiming to find good will around people doing open source was an outright lie that did not deliver what it promised and this was all done on HN. When a company lies for something that trivial, it does not inspire trust
- fasterik 7mo ago
  It's an outright lie because they haven't greenlit your personal project after two weeks? Did it occur to you that maybe they just got a lot of applications and are prioritizing other projects or still working through a backlog?
- 3371 7mo ago
  They would be 100% lying if they have infinite budget allocated to this campaign and haven't approved all requests.

benterix 7mo ago

I just checked your projects, it looks just like something I was looking for. And I hope in a few weeks the guys from Anthropic will give you what they promised. However, since we're frank here, I'd say I'll download the most recent release and be very careful about upgrading because I don't put much trust in projects co-created with LLMs. I know there is a full spectrum but I've seen enough and I don't have the resources to check where on the spectrum your project ends up. LLMs are a powerful drug and terribly hard to stop once you start.

mickael-kerjean 7mo ago
> I don't put much trust in projects co-created with LLMs Its not, there is history since 2017 and I've been working on this full time