6 ms·
A Singaporean friend of mine just saw my posting of the same United States editorial on my Facebook wall, and she suggested the 29 October 2012 article "A less
by tokenadult 14y ago
A Singaporean friend of mine just saw my posting of the same United States editorial on my Facebook wall, and she suggested the 29 October 2012 article "A less exam-centric approach to build character, creativity,"
http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC121029-0000030/A-less-exam-centric-approach-to-build-character,-creativity http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC121029-0000030/A-les...
featuring quotations from a speech by Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam of Singapore as a possible response. It does appear that people respond to incentives, and the Singapore education system has set up pretty good incentives for one set of behaviors, with an ongoing debate in that slowly democratizing society about what behaviors to encourage for the next stage of Singapore's development.
AFTER EDIT: I just reread all the other comments in this thread, in light of what they are saying in response to one another. I should respond to a couple that come from someone evidently much younger than I am, who has spent time in Singapore as a foreign resident (with what language background?).
At the top comment level:
Foreign languages are almost never taught
Grandchild to that comment (from same HN participant):
The three ethnic groups in Singapore
As a member of the older generation, I can remember when Singapore had a lot more than the current "three ethnic groups" (that would be Chinese, Malay, and Indian, by the reckoning of Singapore) as an actual linguistic matter. To both points, by the Singapore government's own statistics,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Singapore#Languages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Singapore#Langu...
as recently as 1990 there was no one language of the four languages that are official in Singapore--Malay, (Modern Standard) Chinese, English, and Tamil--that was even spoken at home in the majority of homes in Singapore. School instruction has been in English since independence in 1965, but only a tiny minority of the population spoke English at home in my generation. I would have to consider a country that has four official languages from four different language families, NONE of which the plurality of the population spoke at home just a generation ago, a very successful country in teaching second languages. And if today people in Singapore think that "Chinese" is one ethnic group, they have forgotten a lot of ethnic division between Hokkien speakers and Hakka speakers and Cantonese speakers (who speak mutually incomprehensible Sinitic languages, all of which I have studied in addition to Mandarin) that is also very recent history in that country and other parts of the Chinese-speaking world.