3 ms·
Countries which increased their investment in education tended to have slower economic growth, at least in the period 1960-2000. Education policy has long been
by tokenadult 14y ago
Countries which increased their investment in education tended to have slower economic growth, at least in the period 1960-2000.
Education policy has long been a research topic for me, and it is the topic that drew me here to Hacker News.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4728123 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4728123
The quoted statement is where equating "spending taxpayer money on schools" to "investing in education" leads to some odd policy conclusions. A friend of mine (a man in my generation, a policy analyst for the United States federal government) showed me that blog post the day it was posted (I think he is a regular reader of that blog) and asked me to comment about it. If the factual question is, is spending-as-such strongly correlated with results from a country's school system? we already know from multiple lines of evidence that the answer is no.
http://www.oecd.org/pisa/49685503.pdf http://www.oecd.org/pisa/49685503.pdf
But what is remarkable about Singapore is that even when it didn't have the economic development yet to spend much on schools it was already spending wisely and otherwise getting good results for all aspects of its national investment, financial and nonfinancial, in education.
http://www.merga.net.au/documents/RP182006.pdf http://www.merga.net.au/documents/RP182006.pdf
I'm even more familiar with the situation in Taiwan than I am with the situation in Singapore, and EFFECTIVE spending and management (not lavish spending, and not school-favoring management) of the public education system there has to share part of the credit for the transformation of Taiwan in my lifetime from a wretchedly poor country to a prosperous country on track to be one of the wealthiest countries in the world in my old age.
http://www.globalpost.com/globalpost-blogs/southeast-asia/singapore-richest-country http://www.globalpost.com/globalpost-blogs/southeast-asia/si...
I have seen the textbooks from both countries (especially from Taiwan). They are less expensive to produce, and thus less of a cost burden on the school system, than the textbooks used in the United States. But the textbooks are of much higher quality, especially in mathematics. In two generations, we have seen those countries transform into countries such that many foreign observers assume that people are "naturally" smart in those countries. I know enough people from enough strata of society and a broad enough age range from each country to know that today's appearance that east Asia and southeast Asia are full of smart people is because of smart policies that helped the two most recent generations in the top-performing countries gain exceptionally good educations at reasonable cost. Yes, some countries could spend less on their schools and do better than they do now, if only they would spend more wisely.
- guylhem 14y agoEducation policy is interesting. What drove me to HN was that it had a better community that slashdot - but what drives me now is the quality of the content and the discussion, especially for economic ideas which challenge the theories I'm learning. That's quite interesting - education efficiency (or effectiveness as you say) seem to matter a lot. The Pritchett study reported by yummyfajitas (which is someone I highly regard, for his post are generally spot on and instructive) adds to this that increasing education duration has been disproven to have an efficiency on growth (which complements the Romer/Lucas models of growth I'm learning) You further that by disproving the relation between spending and school system results. The conclusion seems to be that while money and time might not be important, the educational content is more important, and country even with few resources or teachers could focus their effort on the right content to maximize their results. Very interesting indeed.