4 ms·
There has to be a point where we just throw our hands up and say the person deserves a darwin award. I don't think there has really been any epidemic concern o
by jlgreco 14y ago
There has to be a point where we just throw our hands up and say the person deserves a darwin award. I don't think there has really been any epidemic concern over teenagers swallowing these though, and I don't think younger children use these as fake piercings.
- tptacek 14y agoWell then you're proposing that we should have issued 1,700 "Darwin awards" since just 2009, almost all of them to small children. I think it's much less likely that you actually mean this, and more likely that you haven't read much about the CPSC's side of this story.
- jlgreco 14y agoI think it is pretty clear that I am refering to teenagers eating magnets getting a Darwin award, not children..... Talk about uncharitable interpretations.
- tptacek 14y agoI think it's pretty clear that I don't think you're OK with little kids being hurt by magnets.
- jlgreco 14y agoIs being obtuse a sport for you?
- yew 14y agoSeriously?
- tptacek 14y agoYes. I thought saying "I think it's unlikely you actually think little kids should get Darwin awards" communicated that he wasn't writing callously, but just hadn't considered the CPSC's side.
- yew 14y agoMostly I just got the impression of someone trying to invoke condescension. Have you just never heard of cost-benefits? Otherwise, elaborating a bit more might make your points less opaque.
- shrughes 14y agocost/benefit? There are plenty of affordable substitute goods for toy magnets.
- yew 14y agoThat's one source of negative utility in this case. A general cost-benefit analysis of this policy decision would need to take into account quite a few more. Anyway, I was referring to tptacek's apparent failure to consider that someone might think some finite number of deaths acceptable.
- tptacek 14y agoI have no problem with that. The only issue I have is when people cast a data-driven policy decision about a relatively dangerous novelty item as some kind of ignorant overreach.
- yew 14y ago'Ignorant overreach' is a value judgment, even if it doesn't sound quite like one. We can disagree about which data is relevant and how it should drive policy, and end up right back where we started. The only ways out (that I can see) are to either talk about the disagreement itself or ignore each other and go back to lobbyist fights.
- yew 14y agoGiven your continued insistence on trying to change the argument to one about the elimination of all small round magnets, I can only assume that you're either trolling or just completely unwilling to think about other people's positions. You certainly don't come across as stupid enough for it to be anything else.
- DanBC 14y agoWell, that escalated. I kind of agree. That's why I mentioned chainsaws. This instruction manuel for a Stihl chainsaw is, I think, good. There are many pages of warnings. Most of them are informative and address real problems - page 4 talks about why this chainsaw is a special use saw. There are no "Don't hold the wrong end" warnings here. (http://www.stihlusa.com/WebContent/CMSFileLibrary/instructionmanuals/STIHL020T_with_safety_manual.pdf http://www.stihlusa.com/WebContent/CMSFileLibrary/instructio...) Some things are dangerous. Everyone can reasonably know they're dangerous, and we don't need to withdraw those items from sale. Other items are dangerous, but those dangers are not obvious, and even though we put warnings on the objects we still find people being harmed. Again, I'm not sure that harm is enough to force some items off the market. Maybe just bigger, better, warnings.