2 ms·
Witness my favorite renegade intellectual, Robert Pirsig I went to high school with a classmate who used to have the Pirsig family over for dinner fairly regul
by tokenadult 14y ago
Witness my favorite renegade intellectual, Robert Pirsig
I went to high school with a classmate who used to have the Pirsig family over for dinner fairly regularly. Robert Pirsig's father Maynard Pirsig was a law professor at the University of Minnesota, where the classmate's father (and, years later, I) studied for a law degree. I think, having read only Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance among Robert Pirsig's writings, and after limited personal acquaintance with Maynard Pirsig, that Robert Pirsig takes a lawyer's "that's debatable" attitude as he approaches scientific and philosophical questions, which bogs down his quest for certainty.
AFTER EDIT: I've seen an interesting pattern of drive-by voting on this comment, but I'd like to know more about what other people who are acquainted with the writings of Maynard Pirsig (father) and Robert Pirsig (son) think about the influence of the one writer on the other.
- sesqu 14y agoI'm not familiar with the Pirsigs, but I certainly do not consider the attitude in question to be lawyerlike. While lawyers do occasionally face philosophical conundrums, they also tend to have the desired answer known to them. This is considerably easier than to, say, set a prior for the domain of a model parameter, where your preferences are in a vague war between convenience and justice. The internal debate arises when working from first principles and finding too few.
- nacker 14y agoInteresting. I first read ZAMM first when I was 15, and really enjoyed it, but I would strongly encourage everyone who has not read "Lila" to please read it, as Pirsig basically retracts most of what he said in ZAMM. In his own words, "Lila" is his "smart child", and the book he wants to be remembered by. It is a much better book than ZAMM. If anyone is interested, I just discovered William James Sidis's "The Animate And The Inanimate" here: http://www.sidis.net/ANIMContents.htm http://www.sidis.net/ANIMContents.htm