4 ms·
Lets be honest, unless you are a toddler (and these magnet toy companies are very careful to make it known these are not for children, so if a child gets a hold
by jlgreco 14y ago
Lets be honest, unless you are a toddler (and these magnet toy companies are very careful to make it known these are not for children, so if a child gets a hold of these an adult is to blame...), you are probably not in the habit of eating things just because they are small. What are they going to do, jump down your throat?
- DanBC 14y agoSome people use strong magnets as fake tongue or cheek piercings. (http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/7393684/Fake-piercings-put-teens-at-risk http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/7393684/Fake-piercing...) I'm not saying this is a valid reason to ban the sale of these items. (Sell anything, so long as you make clear warnings about non-obvious risks. Thus, a chainsaw doesn't need much warnings, because it's a chainsaw. But little magnetic balls which are very appealing to children but also dangerous - yep, give them some clear warnings.)
- jlgreco 14y agoThere has to be a point where we just throw our hands up and say the person deserves a darwin award. I don't think there has really been any epidemic concern over teenagers swallowing these though, and I don't think younger children use these as fake piercings.
- tptacek 14y agoWell then you're proposing that we should have issued 1,700 "Darwin awards" since just 2009, almost all of them to small children. I think it's much less likely that you actually mean this, and more likely that you haven't read much about the CPSC's side of this story.
- jlgreco 14y agoI think it is pretty clear that I am refering to teenagers eating magnets getting a Darwin award, not children..... Talk about uncharitable interpretations.
- tptacek 14y agoI think it's pretty clear that I don't think you're OK with little kids being hurt by magnets.
- jlgreco 14y agoIs being obtuse a sport for you?
- yew 14y agoSeriously?
- tptacek 14y agoYes. I thought saying "I think it's unlikely you actually think little kids should get Darwin awards" communicated that he wasn't writing callously, but just hadn't considered the CPSC's side.
- yew 14y agoMostly I just got the impression of someone trying to invoke condescension. Have you just never heard of cost-benefits? Otherwise, elaborating a bit more might make your points less opaque.
- shrughes 14y agocost/benefit? There are plenty of affordable substitute goods for toy magnets.
- yew 14y agoThat's one source of negative utility in this case. A general cost-benefit analysis of this policy decision would need to take into account quite a few more. Anyway, I was referring to tptacek's apparent failure to consider that someone might think some finite number of deaths acceptable.
- DanBC 14y agoWell, that escalated. I kind of agree. That's why I mentioned chainsaws. This instruction manuel for a Stihl chainsaw is, I think, good. There are many pages of warnings. Most of them are informative and address real problems - page 4 talks about why this chainsaw is a special use saw. There are no "Don't hold the wrong end" warnings here. (http://www.stihlusa.com/WebContent/CMSFileLibrary/instructionmanuals/STIHL020T_with_safety_manual.pdf http://www.stihlusa.com/WebContent/CMSFileLibrary/instructio...) Some things are dangerous. Everyone can reasonably know they're dangerous, and we don't need to withdraw those items from sale. Other items are dangerous, but those dangers are not obvious, and even though we put warnings on the objects we still find people being harmed. Again, I'm not sure that harm is enough to force some items off the market. Maybe just bigger, better, warnings.
- tptacek 14y agoLet's be honest, virtually no teenager in the world could be trusted to ensure that no 2 out of the 216 tiny rolling metal balls that come in one of these sets ever got lost in their house. Meanwhile, yes, putting shiny metal things into their mouths is essentially the full time job of a toddler. The problem isn't that magnets are inherently unsafe, or even that tiny round magnets are unsafe. It's that this particular packaging of tiny round magnets is unsafe. There's a lot of really fun things a conscientious person can do with fire, electricity, strong acid, or liquid nitrogen. But nobody's been dumb enough to put them in colorful packages with "Not For Children Under 14" on the label.
- jlgreco 14y agoThere are a hell of a lot of things that we could ban if we wanted to make sure children never found dangerous things. The only reason small magnet toys get grief is because they are new and novel enough to stand out from the crowd and get the attention.
- tptacek 14y agoThat's a viewpoint I probably can't talk you out of. But just to give a concise repetition of my viewpoint: the reason small magnet toys get grief is the gap between how dangerous they actually are and how not dangerous they appear to be.
- jlgreco 14y agoThere are thousands of poisoning deaths every year^. Yet we still market children's vitamins that look like candy in drug bottles similar to those used for prescription medication, and we still sell industrial cleaners with colouring that should make kool-aid jealous. Nobody cares, because everybody is used to these things. We are satisfied when manufactures put nasty labels on the bottles. There is a gap between how dangerous magnets technically can be when ingested, and the actual harm they are causing. Yeah, if you swallow them you are pretty much due for an ER visit... but in reality this is an edge case that we should not be wasting our time worrying about. ^ http://www.cdc.gov/homeandrecreationalsafety/Poisoning/poisoning-factsheet.htm http://www.cdc.gov/homeandrecreationalsafety/Poisoning/poiso...
- mikeash 14y agoI'd wager that a small but significant fraction of people will play with these things in their mouth (sticking them on either side of their tongue, for example) and accidentally swallowing them at that point is not hard to accomplish. And no, people shouldn't be doing this, but these things look completely harmless. They're not poisonous and they're small enough to pass without harm, so what's the big deal? I think that's what it comes down to. The danger these things pose isn't terribly large, but it's far larger than what a typical reasonable person would perceive as the danger.