4 ms·
Education dominates Singapore's 'different' culture
- codewright 14y agoHacker News clearly has a strong interest in education, I find this interesting because I see misguided attempts in trying to educate the masses on HN. The tone comes off the wrong way and it hurts the substantive content coming from the knowledge many HN contributors have to offer. Some thoughts for HNers and their future attempts at educating others in this forum: The comment threads are here for conversations and the exchange of thought, not for the assignment of homework in the form of white papers/books. Mentioning your sources I'm sure is always welcome, but many seem to assume that anybody who hasn't read the same material as themselves is somehow incapable of contributing to a conversation on the subject at hand. That is an egregiously poisonous mindset. If you want to make the most of your time on HN have more respect for others and synthesize your knowledge. Let a conversation happen. By all means link your sources, but say what you're going to say and don't assign homework. Contextual synthesis > PDF That's my $0.02 (not denominated in Verizon-units). --- With that out of the way --- More related to the article, I've visited Singapore and know a few Singaporeans. One of the main takeaways was that they're hyper-competitive and aggressive in ways I'm not sure US gov'ts/voters would ever really countenance for the sake of progress. The article is rife with Orientalist gawking and murmuring of approval. Typical for the current mode of reporting on how Asia does things differently than the West. (Cf. Friedman's absurd pseudo-capitalist posturing on China) Mentioning the chewing gum ban, seriously? Money quote: "But it's really more about discipline than intelligence."
- dkarl 14y agoThe article is rife with Orientalist gawking and murmuring of approval. Typical for the current mode of reporting on how anybody in Asia does things. It's superficial, to be sure, but at least it lets Singaporeans speak for themselves about the cultural difference. The true purpose of the article seems to be to say some things about Cleveland that can't be said directly, so a more nuanced take on Singapore might be beside the point.
- codewright 14y agoIt's better than others I've seen, for sure. I'm just not familiar enough with Cleveland (other than knowing it's a disaster zone) to really know how this article is supposed to reflect upon circumstances there. I can hardly believe anything more than a tiny fraction of HN readership is familiar with the situation there either, so I have to go with the more obvious parts. I'm not an English Lit major, I'm not super-interested in deep meta-analysis of author intentions.
- newman314 14y ago"Orientalist" Pardon my French, but WTF?
- forgottenpaswrd 14y ago"And no one would dispute that the key to all this success has been education." I would. Singapore is what it is because of their strategic placing in the wold today. The only reason the English decided to convert this tropical island in the commerce nucleus it is. People always rationalize how when something good happens to them it is always because of their merit alone. Spain discovered America because it is on the extreme of Europe and not in the center, Germany is an Industrial nation because it has so much water and coal, and is very cheap to transport things and USA has the bigger and most fertile plains in the world for a very small population. Now ask an American, German or a person from Singapore what is the key of success and they will tell you hard work of course, but they don't work harder than people from Central African Republic(I had been there, very beautiful and rich but in the middle of nowhere, with no infrastructure, and very poor).
- ewolf 14y agoTrue, the article certainly leaves out a lot there. I would, however, attribute Singapore's success to their own good leadership. The Brits certainly were not the ones who developed it to what it is today.
- effinjames 14y agoThe jews did bro, amen.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI would dispute that education is the key to all this success as well. Let us assume that educational outcomes (i.e., human capital as measured by test scores) are the driver of this success. Even making this assumption, the bulk of the gap in educational outcomes between the US and Singapore is probably not due to education. The US 8th grade PISA score is 495, whereas that of Singapore is 540. But Asian Americans have a score of 535. Several American states have Asian students who even exceed Singapore, specifically NY, TX and CT. http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2011/01/how-well-do-above-average-american.html http://super-economy.blogspot.com/2011/01/how-well-do-above-... If education were the primary driver of educational outcomes, that shouldn't happen. So we should reject education as the primary driver of educational outcomes. However, the article also suggests a cultural explanation: "it's built into our [Singaporean] culture to study all the way through school". If Asian Americans share this trait but non-Asian Americans do not, this is certainly consistent with the data.
- ewolf 14y agoThis is a very simplified view of the education system in Singapore. Of course education should be important, but it can also go too far. I've been in Singapore for 1 year as an exchange student. While I managed to cope well, many slightly less talented students suffer from the great workload and have almost no free time. In a middle class secondary school, about 95% of the children need tuition to keep up with school. Weeks or even months before their exams, all free time is eliminated and dedicated to studying. The learning itself isn't perfect either. It's heavily focused on memorization and involves no oral participation. Foreign languages are almost never taught; math and natural sciences matter the most. Competition is promoted instead of teamwork (not only amongst students, but also amongst teachers and civil servants in general). The teachers are ranked according to their students' results, which does work as a motivator, but discourages them to explain any background information or topics that are not required from exams. Parents urge their children to get the best degree they can in order to be able to take up the best paying job they can find. Money is the measure and not personal satisfaction. Arts, therefore, are not very popular. I'm highlighting here all negative aspects to contrast the posted article; of course it is good that Singapore does promote education and the education system certainly works better than the ones of most other countries. Also, this is not directly related to Singapore, but represents the Confucianist mentality that one can find to a lot extremer extents in Japan, China and Korea.
- guylhem 14y ago> (competition, no foreign languages, science first) > Parents urge their children to get the best degree they can in order to be able to take up the best paying job they can find. Money is the measure and not personal satisfaction. Arts, therefore, are not very popular. > I'm highlighting here all negative aspects It does not look like negatives to me, but a recipe for success - ie focus on the important and cut the useless. (And in a country with as many immigrants as Singapore, I'm sure the issue of foreign languages is self solving :-)
- zhemao 14y agoYou are making the BIG assumption that foreign languages, the humanities, teamwork, and learning other than rote memorization are useless. It takes more than knowing a lot of facts and being able to crunch numbers to be successful in a career, even in technical ones like science and engineering. Successful scientists and engineers not only have strong technical skills, but also strong "soft" skills, like the ability to effectively communicate ideas and work in a team.
- jasonjei 14y agoI wonder, though, if there is a software business in Singapore that is on the same level as Microsoft, Adobe, Oracle, Google, Apple, VMware, etc, as well as the Linux foundation and FSF being present in Singapore. The US may not have the best education system, but I wonder if it is the lax education that has fostered the software industry (as well as engineering, HP, anybody?) in the US.
- ewolf 14y agoWhile Singapore may not foster a startup culture as it can be found in many parts of the USA, a population of 5 million (with 1/3 immigrants) is certainly hard to compare to 308 million.
- aen 14y agoWe're extremely good at some things but at the expense of everything else. Thus our lives generally aren't very interesting. I'm a pretty smart guy (140± IQ) who dropped out of the system when I was 15 and went through non-systematic but relentless self-education. The learning habits formed in school helped. But I was 'free'. My point is whatever the status quo, there will be a minority that will abandon the system taking along with them only the good parts and then become interesting. So with a bigger population, you get more of such minority which causes Microsofts, Googles and Apples to happen.
- darylteo 14y agoSingaporean here. My biggest gripe with Singapore's state as it is (and why can't we criticize it?) is that while Singapore does have a stronger emphasis on education (GREAT!), it still falls behind in knowledge. Singapore has no natural resource, and thus no natural export. Its main exports (other than "tourism" which doesn't count) is through secondary products like petroleum, and through its workforce, considered high-value by companies around the world. Its workforce, being a resource, is therefore treated like a resource. And resources must always be more readily available, more efficiently farmed, more accurately quantified. The only way to survive in this country is to go through the gauntlet, and get stamped with a quality grade like beef. My personal hope for the future of Singapore is to slowly make the transition away from treating its humans as a workforce resource, and to start treasuring their humans as a knowledge bank. Indeed, I believe Singapore has realised this, with its growing bio-technology sector, A* etc. However it is a race against time; unlike other resources, its workforce can turn against it. No I'm not really speaking about revolution etc. But years of being a resource has put a toll on the population... just as a engine that is run in overdrive for too long wears out. Many of the Singaporeans who can afford to find a better life elsewhere, where their knowledge is valued higher, are doing so. Those that do not have that knowledge are simply resigned to being the nation's workhorse, and take no effort to seek it themselves (or perhaps they cannot afford to). This puts Singapore in a weird position. It is suffering from "brain drain". And the current remedy for it is importing knowledge from elsewhere. Unlike regions like the US, EU, AU, where populations are made up of many varieties of cultures, Singapore is a young country with only 3 major ethnic groups, and outsiders are viewed as such. This further axacerbates the feeling that local workers are just their workers. Anyway, after that long blob, my 2nd personal hope is I may be able to return to my country and contribute back, not through workhours, but through knowledge. Disclaimer: this is all my views and intuition, I don't have any links or numbers to back things up.
- tokenadult 14y agoA Singaporean friend of mine just saw my posting of the same United States editorial on my Facebook wall, and she suggested the 29 October 2012 article "A less exam-centric approach to build character, creativity," http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC121029-0000030/A-less-exam-centric-approach-to-build-character,-creativity http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC121029-0000030/A-les... featuring quotations from a speech by Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam of Singapore as a possible response. It does appear that people respond to incentives, and the Singapore education system has set up pretty good incentives for one set of behaviors, with an ongoing debate in that slowly democratizing society about what behaviors to encourage for the next stage of Singapore's development. AFTER EDIT: I just reread all the other comments in this thread, in light of what they are saying in response to one another. I should respond to a couple that come from someone evidently much younger than I am, who has spent time in Singapore as a foreign resident (with what language background?). At the top comment level: Foreign languages are almost never taught Grandchild to that comment (from same HN participant): The three ethnic groups in Singapore As a member of the older generation, I can remember when Singapore had a lot more than the current "three ethnic groups" (that would be Chinese, Malay, and Indian, by the reckoning of Singapore) as an actual linguistic matter. To both points, by the Singapore government's own statistics, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Singapore#Languages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Singapore#Langu... as recently as 1990 there was no one language of the four languages that are official in Singapore--Malay, (Modern Standard) Chinese, English, and Tamil--that was even spoken at home in the majority of homes in Singapore. School instruction has been in English since independence in 1965, but only a tiny minority of the population spoke English at home in my generation. I would have to consider a country that has four official languages from four different language families, NONE of which the plurality of the population spoke at home just a generation ago, a very successful country in teaching second languages. And if today people in Singapore think that "Chinese" is one ethnic group, they have forgotten a lot of ethnic division between Hokkien speakers and Hakka speakers and Cantonese speakers (who speak mutually incomprehensible Sinitic languages, all of which I have studied in addition to Mandarin) that is also very recent history in that country and other parts of the Chinese-speaking world.
- effinjames 14y agoInsignificant little country that nobody really care.
- smirksirlot 14y agoI grew up in Singapore and went through the education system there before moving to North America at 16. Singapore isn't really the "education heaven" that it is made out to be. The biggest different I would say is that Singapore education churns out book-smart students. These are the people who are best at following instructions, steps, and established methods. We're very good at following and reinforcing the paths well trod. Coming to North America, while I did far better than my peers in strict academic settings, they would constantly do better in things such as dealing with people, creative activities etc. People here have a better sense of adventure and are willing to challenge themselves/the status quo to experience the world.
- balsam 14y agoWhat percentage of successful HN applicants are Singaporean? I know at least half (he was born there), but it could be a interesting number to know.
- yzhengyu 14y agoSingaporean here. The article is a typical outsider view of our system, which isn't as perfect as it sounds. In the first place, the majority of Singapore's successes is largely due to a pro-business policy which has attracted massive amounts of foreign direct investment. In the second place, my observation is that in general Singaporeans are well-schooled, not well educated. As Mark Twain put it, there is a difference. And there is also the uglier side of a hyper-competitive system which darylteo has pointed out. And then you ask yourself, where do the "losers" of this competition end up? The challenge at this stage is to ensure we move our lowest gear up - and I can assure you, our lowest gear is pretty low. Unfortunately, unless the technocrats get mind-transplants from the people who did the Finnish or Danish model, I don't think its going to change.
- rkwz 14y ago>And then you ask yourself, where do the "losers" of this competition end up? Where do they end up?
- ramgorur 14y agoA very nice read. But are "a good schooling" and "a good learning" same? I have seen many folks with good schooling and with perfect GPAs, but most of them are only good at sitting and scoring in exams :-S.