8 ms·
CEO Craig Zucker on the Demise of Buckyballs
- Gring 14y agoBuckyballs are just magnets of a certain material, shape, and size. There are countless shops on- and offline that sell the exactly same product, among other types, shapes and sizes, to consumers and professionals, sometimes to both. How is the CPSC planning to implement this ban? Prohibit this exact combination? Or ban everybody that sells them in a package that looks vaguely toy-like? Are they ok if the packaging looks boring and industrial? Where do they draw the line? The CPSC is going to have a lot of explaining to do.
- tptacek 14y agoIt's not complicated. It will simply become unlawful to sell "aggregations of separable, permanent, magnetic objects intended or marketed by the manufacturer primarily as a manipulative or construction desk toy for general entertainment, such as puzzle working, sculpture building, mental stimulation, or stress relief." Contrary to knee-jerk Internet opinion, the CPSC is not out to rid the country of small round magnets.
- davorb 14y agoThis was featured on Reason.tv. Sad to see them lose this battle. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KONkQx0wm1c http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KONkQx0wm1c
- cpeterso 14y agoThe health risk of swallowing Buckyballs is more serious than just swallowing a marble. If you swallow two or more magnets, they can get stuck together as they wind their way through your intestines and pinch holes through your intestinal wall.
- colmvp 14y agoWell it's a good thing I tend to not put non-edible items in my mouth.
- jlgreco 14y agoLets be honest, unless you are a toddler (and these magnet toy companies are very careful to make it known these are not for children, so if a child gets a hold of these an adult is to blame...), you are probably not in the habit of eating things just because they are small. What are they going to do, jump down your throat?
- DanBC 14y agoSome people use strong magnets as fake tongue or cheek piercings. (http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/7393684/Fake-piercings-put-teens-at-risk http://www.stuff.co.nz/national/health/7393684/Fake-piercing...) I'm not saying this is a valid reason to ban the sale of these items. (Sell anything, so long as you make clear warnings about non-obvious risks. Thus, a chainsaw doesn't need much warnings, because it's a chainsaw. But little magnetic balls which are very appealing to children but also dangerous - yep, give them some clear warnings.)
- jlgreco 14y agoThere has to be a point where we just throw our hands up and say the person deserves a darwin award. I don't think there has really been any epidemic concern over teenagers swallowing these though, and I don't think younger children use these as fake piercings.
- tptacek 14y agoWell then you're proposing that we should have issued 1,700 "Darwin awards" since just 2009, almost all of them to small children. I think it's much less likely that you actually mean this, and more likely that you haven't read much about the CPSC's side of this story.
- jlgreco 14y agoI think it is pretty clear that I am refering to teenagers eating magnets getting a Darwin award, not children..... Talk about uncharitable interpretations.
- tedivm 14y agoBuckyballs are extremely low quality and fall apart quite easily. Zenmagnets are much higher quality, and seem to be taking more and more of the market share away from the Buckyball guys. I think that may explain why Buckyballs folded while Zenmagnets are still fighting this ( http://www.zenmagnets.com/index.php?p=1_20_November_Update http://www.zenmagnets.com/index.php?p=1_20_November_Update ).
- eropple 14y agoI have some of both and don't really notice a difference. I have some of the Buckycubes--they're pretty nifty.
- tedivm 14y agoI should probably point out that I'm a little obsessed with them- I have a few hundred Buckyballs (various colors and stuff), as well as a couple thousand of the Zenmagnets. The big differences really come in when you're trying to make something delicate or with a larger structure. One major issue is consistency- the sizes between colors or even individual balls in the same set varies quite a bit. If you create a flat plane (one height, whatever length and width) or magnets with both the Zenmagnets and the Buckyballs, the Zenmagnets will be level all around while the Buckyballs have different sized. This causes some to bulge out, making that level plane actually quiet bumpy looking. The other problem is that the coating they use over the actual neodymium is very cheap. The longer you own the Buckyballs the more of it breaks off. The Zenmagnets are going to last quite a bit longer, and not break down in your hands just because you let them snap together too hard.
- gav 14y agoWhen I was trying to look up an article from about the call to "redesign" hot dogs, I found this quote: "No parents can watch all of their kids 100% of the time. The best way to protect kids is to design these risks out of existence." -- Gary Smith, director of the Center for Injury Research and Policy at Nationwide Children's Hospital in Columbus, Ohio http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/2010-02-22-1Achoke22_ST_N.htm http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/health/2010-02-22-1Achok... I feel that this is a sad state of affairs.
- anothermachine 14y agoWhy? Seems like a smart solution to a problem. We have designed many of the risks out of cars too, and I for one appreciate that.
- Gormo 14y agoIt is a smart solution to the problem, to an extent: mitigating risks in ways that are unrelated to the intended functionality of the product is usually a good idea. But mitigating risks inherent to the nature of the product in a way that reduces the product's functionality, reliability, or adaptability for other purposes isn't an appropriate solution. More broadly, and more importantly, designing risk out of our environment gives us less fodder for the development of our own faculties for risk judgment, and therefore makes us more dependent on external articles and less so on intelligence and caution for our safety, and this ironically makes is more risky for us to explore aspects of the world which haven't been already made artificially safe, and more subject to danger if the external sources of risk should shift. In other words, maintaining risk-free environments ultimately makes us less adaptable, makes the prospect of change riskier, and therefore reduces our evolutionary fitness.
- tptacek 14y agoZucker is being a little misleading about this. His firm did indeed have a long relationship with the CPSC, and throughout that relationship, no matter what their firm did to mitigate the risks their magnets had to children, reports of life threatening injuries not only continued but increased. The CPSC didn't kill their product for sport; they acted based on the empirical evidence. You'd wonder, reading this article, what problem CPSC had with a simple magnetic toy set. After all, nowhere in this article do the words "surgery" or "intestinal perforation" occur. The problem is simple. A child can swallow a penny, or even a nail(!), and the ER doctors will send them home to wait for it to pass. But if you happen to swallow two tiny rare earth magnets, what can happen is that they latch together on opposing sides of loops of small intestine, gradually digging their way through the tissue and spilling gut bacteria into the abdominal cavity, which results in sepsis. "[W]hen these high-‐powered magnets are swallowed, endoscopic or surgical intervention is required in nearly all cases to prevent bowel damage." - Nerissa S. Bauer, MD, MPH, Assistant Professor Indiana University School of Medicine Skateboarding is probably statistically more dangerous than tiny rare earth magnets. But parents know how to mitigate the risks of skateboarding. My guess is that 80% of the parents on Hacker News don't even know that swallowing a tiny smooth round magnet is more dangerous to a toddler than swallowing a nail. Certainly teenagers don't understand this, because they were using Buckyball magnets to hold fake lip piercing studs. Zucker's firm attempted to address the problem with warning labels. But how do you put warning labels on a set of 100 tiny metal balls? Even if the label read "DO NOT EVER LEAVE THESE OUT OF THE BOX", which they don't and can't because keeping them out of the box is a big part of the point of the toy, what good is that going to do when a teenager buys a set and leaves it on his desk in the house he shares with a 4 year old? Because that is not an uncommon scenario. In the end, the issue here is not that the government thinks it should be unlawful to sell small rare earth magnets. It's that the government thinks companies shouldn't be able to profit from selling them as direct-to-consumer toys and novelty items. If CSPC is seeing marked increases in injuries due to magnets now, when the products are in their early-adopter infancy (there are, according to Zen Magnets, only two companies selling sets like this as consumer products), the CPSC can reasonably assume that the damage would be much worse as the products mainstreamed. Buy the magnets online, or from a lab supply store, and give them the respect they deserve.
- 14y ago
- patrickgzill 14y agoSo now, only outlaws will have Buckyballs?
- tptacek 14y agoNo, small sets of 200 tiny round rare earth magnets remain perfectly legal to possess or even to sell. The only thing you can't do is market them as desk toys.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]